A FJG would reinforce women’s oppression by incorporating them into gendered workplaces, denying them caregiving roles, and maintaining the “work ethic” behind the stigmatization of “Women’s Work”
Karcher, 2018 – winner Best Undergraduate Paper in Labor Studies from the Bridges Center for Labor Studies at the Univ of Washington [Kathryn, Mar 4, 2018-2019 “Pursuing Social Justice: How Might a Universal Basic Income or Federal Jobs Guarantee Help Women? https://digital.lib.washington.edu/researchworks/handle/1773/43803?show=full AC]
Like UBI, implementing FJG would undermine women’s oppression by providing them with the financial security necessary for escaping exploitative household environments. However, it is unclear that this option is accessible for many women. The caregiving work that many women are expected to perform at home could present substantial barriers that make it harder for women to use a full-time job as an exit option. As many scholars have noted when considering workplace inequality, direct and indirect financial penalties exist when women attempt to combine paid work with caregiving responsibilities.127 A woman-friendly jobs guarantee would need to account for this fact and accommodate women’s life patterns, not just men’s, possibly by basing their workplace design on Nancy Fraser’s description of a universal caregiver model. Instead of making women more like men, this model induces “men to become more like most women are now” by “dismantling the gendered opposition between breadwinning and caregiving” and encouraging men and women to embrace both paid, formal and unpaid, caregiving labor.128 A jobs guarantee like this may undermine exploitation, but a guarantee that resembles New Deal work programs would not. The potential for FJG to undermine exploitation, then, largely depends on the type of jobs guarantee implemented. Unlike UBI, FJG would not necessarily help those facing exploitation in the workplace. Instead, it risks establishing an alternative, state-run sphere where workers are exploited. The potential for FJG merely to duplicate an exploitative work environment depends upon the type of FJG implemented. If the jobs that workers perform does not produce a profit, then no capitalist is extracting “benefits from workers” and thus no structural relations “between social groups” that involve power and inequality are enacted.129 However, it is possible that those who would most benefit from a jobs guarantee—former felons, young workers, poor women, and racial minorities—might replace the exploited workers and the broader White- and male-dominated society might replace the capitalists. Although the latter would not be receiving a profit from the former’s labor, it would receive benefits in forms such as community services and improved infrastructure. These benefits do not present an exact parallel to profit since they presumably would help everyone but they may still constitute a benefit extracted from workers which implies their exploitation. Although a jobs guarantee which enables workers to give back to their communities may provide an escape from exploitation, the logic that underpins FJG may reinforce the work ethic which renders caregiving labor invisible. FJG “asserts that, if individuals bear a moral duty to work, then society and employers bear a reciprocal moral duty to provide good dignified work for all[.]”130 But his assertion assumes that individuals bear a moral duty to work, and most versions of a jobs guarantee assumes this work should occur under within a traditional workplace environment. These assumptions normalize exploitation and ignore the enormous amount of labor that women perform within their homes. Unless the version of FJG implemented rejects these assumptions, the policy may mirror 1990s welfare reform which urged mothers to work outside the home rather than enabling them to care for their families if they so choose. Although many feminists have spent their careers arguing against the assumption that women’s primary role should be as caregivers, women should still retain the right to follow this life path without being exploited. Affirming women’s right not to work in formal, paid employment that follows traditionally masculine life patterns is especially important considering the experiences of women of color, who have been prevented from caregiving for their families. Offering women a job but not the option to stay home without suffering from exploitation would not help many women. A jobs guarantee which accounts for women’s needs, however, may avoid these pitfalls. Still, FJG risks reinforcing the work ethic which legitimizes exploitation and has rendered women’s caregiving labor invisible. This reinforcement would perpetuate the stigmatization of women, erase their contributions, and thereby make it difficult to point out the exploitation they face. Therefore, FJG risks reinforcing the causes of women’s exploitation and would do a poor job at undermining it .