The concept of “living wage” relies on the “male breadwinner” model of the family—the argument is NOT that the wage system is patriarchal – it is that evaluating how much money is necessary for a Living Wage requires determining how much a family needs to live on, which Presumes that the wife stays home and turns the wage into food, clothes and housing.
Grover, 2005- Professor at Lancaster University [CHRIS GROVER, Lancaster University, “Living wages and the ‘making work pay’ strategy,” Critical Social Policy Vol. 25(1): 5–27, 2005, http://csp.sagepub.com/content/25/1/5.short]
Second, the idea of need is problematic in living wages because of its close association with the concept of the family wage. This issue is recognized in sections of the living wage movement (Brenner, 2002), but has yet to be overcome. This means that living wages are premised upon an androcentric view of wage structures: that a male breadwinner should be able to earn the majority of income for his spouse and dependent children. This is the case in living wages, because, as we have seen, there is an expectation that there will be a full time worker in households. While there is care in living wage literature not to assign this role to men, it is difficult to see how the assumptions of living wages will break from the male breadwinner model. What this means in practice is that living wages can only meet the needs of workers and their families if they conform to the male breadwinner model. Hence, the difficulties demonstrated in Table 1 with delivering higher than the ‘making work pay’ strategy incomes to lone-mother-headed households. If wages were related as closely to need as it is sometimes portrayed in arguments for living wages, those people with dependent children, those working part time and those in families with only one earner would be paid a higher hourly wage compared to those families without dependent children, those with full time earners and those with multiple earners. In other words, those workers who do not conform to the male breadwinner model have potentially the most to gain financially from living wages, but under current proposals they would actually gain the least.