Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Psychoanalysis reduces individuals to behaviors determined by either subconscious or environment. This Essentialization renders individuals vulnerable to manipulation and denial of agency.

Bassiri and Senie 2020 - Department of Philosophy and Religion at American University [Cameron and Matthew “Sarta and the International Impact of Existentialism”, pgs. 349-351, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-38482-1]

The main element of existential philosophy that allows it to offer an alternative to Freudian psychoanalysis and behaviorism is its unique conception of the subject as a situated freedom responsible for itself, its values, and its relations to others, in a word, its non-essentialism. And in truth it is just this Sartrean concept of a subject without an essence that made possible a corresponding form of therapy which both complemented and challenged orthodox Freudian psychoanalysis and behaviorism so effectively. Both of the latter schools, though each in its own way, are defined by what we will term an “essentialization” of the individual. In fact, this view is shared by Rollo May. He writes: “In endeavoring to separate reality into its discrete parts and to formulate abstract laws for these parts, Western science has by and large been essentialist in character” (May 1969b, p. 12). In the case of Freud, the essentialization, or the fixing of the nature, “form,” or essence of the subject, was rooted in his natural-scientific and psychodynamic view of the individual as biologically determined by conflicting unconscious forces. While for Skinner, his essentialization comes in the form of his rejection of “autonomous man,” or any notion of subjectivity at all, and his replacement of it with an organism whose life is its behavior as it has been developed through operant conditioning and which can be understood purely through “a science of behavior.”1 Both schools, then, given their theoretical frameworks and their conceptions of human existence, are psychologies without a subject. As is well known, Freudian psychoanalytic theory conceives of the true individual as a reserve of hidden impulses and drives. Furthermore, to The Psychopathology of Everyday Life, James Strachey writes: “Moreover, there was another fundamental belief of Freud’s which could be convincingly supported by the examination of parapraxes—his belief in the universal application of determinism to mental events. This is the truth which he insists upon in the final chapter of the book: it should be possible in theory to discover the psychical determinants of every smallest detail of the processes of the mind” (Freud 1965, p. 8). The history of the individual, it follows, is determinative of its present, and when a patient enters therapy, it is precisely this history and this causal series that is of central importance. Thus, within the “psychoanalytic situation,” through an exclusive orientation to the past and personal history of the patient, the various psychosexual stages of development, and working through transference, resistance, and so on. psychoanalysis provides insight into the origin of the neurosis of the patient with the ultimate aim of “the translation of what is unconscious into what is conscious. Yes, that is it. By carrying what is unconscious on into what is conscious, we lift the repressions, we remove the preconditions for the formation of symptoms, we transform the pathogenic conflict into a normal one for which it must be possible somehow to find a solution” (Freud 1966, p. 541). This conception of the subject as determined by its unconscious and amenable to “analytic therapy” through the therapeutic apparatus involving free association, resistance, relieving repression, transference, and so on reduces the subject to an identifiable and yet modifiable essence (Arlow 2000; Freud 1966, p. 557, for the complete discussion pp. 557–576). Although an independent school of psychology, behaviorism falls into the same essentializing trap. Rather than plumbing the depths of the unconscious, it is fundamentally concerned with properly understanding and modifying the behavior of the patient. As Wilson has described it in general terms: Applied behavior analysis, derived directly from Skinner’s radical behaviorism, restricts itself to the study of overt behavior and environmental conditions that presumably regulate behavior. Covert, unobservable elements, such as needs, drives, motives, traits, and conflicts, are disregarded. Skinner’s analyses of behavior, for example, are couched in terms of conditioning processes, such as reinforcement, discrimination, and generalization. (Wilson 2000, p. 212) There is no hidden or inner life of the individual, no hermeneutic of associations or dreams designed to reach a cure. There is simply behavior, nothing more and nothing less. The therapist, it follows, attempts to understand the situation within which various behavior patterns were established, that is, the reinforcement achieved through reward and punishment, and then has the task of constructing a scenario to reinforce new behavior meant to replace the old. In this sense, it essentializes the patient by reducing it to behavior. Moreover, the clinical approach essentializes the patient by scientifically understanding it as an organism with behavior patterns which have been formed and can change without consciousness, choice, and, perhaps above all, freedom. Thus, in neither orthodox psychoanalysis nor behaviorism does the analyst empathically engage with the patient as a subject, but rather as a purely natural-scientific object with various symptoms, neuroses, or undesirable behavior patterns in need of modification. The therapist, therefore, observes the patient from the outside, evaluating the data “objectively.” Nevertheless, while there will invariably be nuances to each patient-therapist relationship, the formula for the interaction between the two remains constant, and the essence of the patient—unconscious forces or behavior—is preserved for the therapeutic work to be successful.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.