When confronted with the rhetoric of poverty, we have an ethical obligation to Identify it and stand against its assumptions. Our silence endorses them. Our speech act against them is the only ethical response.
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]
B. THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE READER When we read an opinion dealing with the constitutional status of poverty we are engaged in an activity with moral connotations. After reading the opinion, no morally neutral position is available to us. If we speak about the case, we take on the role and responsibility of the critic. The discourse of the critic is the discourse of normative analysis. In one way or another, we speak of what ought to be. Our membership within the community of law makes even silence a morally charged position. When a member of our community reads, for example, the Wyman case, and is silent, she has chosen not to speak, not to act as a critic, not to engage in explicit normative discourse. She makes this choice after reading an opinion that requires a mother receiving AFDC benefits either to allow the government access to her home, without a warrant and without notice, or to go without the benefits that are essential to feed and care for herself and her child. 208 What reaction to this case is without moral connotation? The very act of reading the Court's poverty cases imposes a responsibility on the reader. We know this responsibility in its other manifestations. If we were members of a church community and read a text from the governing body setting forth the church's position on the ordination of women, we would not imagine that we could read and be silent without moral connotation. If our City Council passed a resolution regarding the rights of gay men and women in the community, we would not suppose that we could read the document and have no responsibility whatsoever for its message. It is the responsibility of a reader within a community to choose a position on the texts that express the community's position on important matters. What, then, is the ethic of reader responsibility? It is to read with the largest measure of care, imagination, and knowledge we can muster. We should recognize the nature and consequences of the choices set forth in the text. We should seek to listen to the arguments of the text, yet break past the confines of those arguments, using our imagination and our knowledge of the world in which these decisions will be played out. We must become the most skillful readers we can be, because the process of reading is always followed by the necessity of our own choice in the matter. A description of poetic metaphor provides a way of thinking about how our responsibility as readers of the Court's poverty cases might be discharged. Max Black, a poetry scholar, created a description of the process whereby a poetic metaphor provides meaning.2°9 Imagine looking at the starry night sky through a piece of painted glass on which several lines have been etched. You would see a night sky through the glass with some stars revealed and others obscured. Experiencing a poetic metaphor is like looking through the etched glass. The metaphor reveals and obscures various parts of its subject, creating a new vision of the subject. 210 The Court's rhetoric is our etched glass and the night sky is the context and legal issues of poverty presented in each case. The reader's responsibility is to look past the night sky as composed by the etched glass of the Court's rhetoric and to see the context and legal issues of poverty as completely as possible. The essential flaw of this allegory as a description of either reading poems or reading the Court's rhetoric of poverty is its suggestion that the subject is a fixed thing, external to the observer. When we encounter a poetic metaphor, our own sense of its subject, whether it is an abstraction like love or a tangible thing like a tree, becomes part of the reading and part of the meaning.211 We face a similar problem in reading the poverty cases. We bring to the reading some idea of poverty. The rhetoric not only seeks to reveal and obscure, it also invites. The reader is invited to supply cultural stereotypes of poverty. It is as though the reader is looking through an etched glass at a night sky that she in part creates by the process of looking. Thus, the reader must not merely see the pieces obscured by the Court's rhetoric, she must realize also that what she sees is in part shaped by the assumptions she brings to the reading. If, for example, she brings the assumption of the moral weakness of the poor to the reading, she must struggle to see that assumption in her reading. She must struggle to bring that assumption out of the murky place of the unstated and assumed into the light of the explicit assertion, where she can judge its truth for herself.