Focusing on work for the poor reinforces the difference between the Deserving and Undeserving poor – this becomes an assumption of moral weakness
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, - MZ]
The dual themes of moral deviance and judicial helplessness at first seem to be inconsistent. The premise of moral weakness suggests that the problem is really quite simple. If poor people simply chose to "straighten up and fly right," all would be well. If they would accept and commit to the moral norms of those of us not in poverty, they would cease to be poor, albeit only after a long time and much hard work. In this vision of poverty, the problem is uni-dimensional and is intractable only to the extent that poor people resist the personal, individual reform of their moral lives. The judicial helplessness theme depends, on the other hand, on the complexity of the problem and on the existence of multiple, intertwined causes. Despite this apparent inconsistency, the Justices-rhetoricians use both themes, often in tandem, throughout their opinions. This apparent inconsistency in the Court's rhetoric of poverty may be related to yet another enduring cultural assumption, the division of the poor into classes of the deserving and the undeserving poor.6 These classes have been drawn somewhat differently throughout history. The contemporary division of the poor distinguishes between able-bodied adults and the children, the aged, and the disabled. This distinction is premised on the ability of the former class to perform work. For this able-bodied class, the moral weakness rhetoric is especially potent-I work, they don't, they could. This argument does not fit members of the second group because we assume that work is not readily available to them. For this class, the judicial helplessness plea is the perfect response. The rhetoric of helplessness allows the expression of sympathy for the deserving poor while avoiding the burden of intervention. The dual rhetoric of moral weakness and judicial helplessness fits the needs of a Court that has chosen to minimize the constitutional basis for intervention on behalf of the poor. Under this rhetoric, either the poor do not deserve our intervention or, if they do have a claim to our sense of justice, we are functionally helpless to do justice.