Talking About the poor is method of constructing the poor as an “Other” – they are discussed, but never have their own voice.
Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]
However, social stigma and political exclusion are likely to follow from the degradation that is often (but not always) associated with economic poverty. Ironic, isn’t it then, that economic poverty continues to be very difficult to ask about in interviews in 2004? Part of the explanation is that economically poor people are usually construed as the other. In English phrasings, statements about ‘the poor’ typically imply that the speaker is automatically designated as non-poor. It is rare indeed for ‘poor’ people to talk about other poor people as such. Indeed one could argue that many people do not want to have a debate about either the poor or poverty. For instance, the UK government under ‘new Labour’ did not want to have a discussion about poverty as such, but rather about wealth creation. Another buzz phrase in use is ‘social protection’. ‘Indices of multiple deprivation’ were constructed. Deprivation would be construed as a failure to properly target and protect these areas. Social protection policies would include benefits and social support as well as pensions. In other words, by framing the scene a certain way, a positive light can be cast upon it, and especially upon the speaker or author. In this way, poverty disappears and something more pleasant – such as meaningfully targetted action - miraculously appears. Iyengar (1990) explains that the framing of poverty affects the politics of poverty. Yapa (1996) presents issues of subjectivity and reality with regard to poverty, helping to clarify how poverty discourses work. The ‘subjective’ realm is the one mainly set up using mental and linguistic constructs. 2 The way poverty is construed is itself a process of social construction. Poor people are construed (often air-brushed) out of existence. Yet poor people do exist, and many of us have personally experienced poverty at given points in life and understand something of what such a life is like. Poverty is a reality for poor people. Many poor people live in Salford. But it’s possible for them and others to collude in hiding the realities of their lives. Not only is the label hidden, but also the real day-to-day difficulties, the hard choices and suffering. In our study, we heard about the use of food stamps, of taking up free school meals, of ostracism and racism during our interviews. Yet always the stories were about ‘other’ people, ‘those’ people. Not us. The social construction of poverty was described by Maia Green as having a long history (2006). Green traces the historical predominance and usage of ‘poverty’ through a variety of schools of thought. These include anthropology in its early decades, the big international institutions as they construe poverty, and more recent normative statements from 1990 onward by global actors. For example, in the context of a debate over supply-side economics and structural adjustment, the ‘poor’ are those whose talents are wasted through bad government. To better use these talents, market forces need to be liberalised, some say, and government corruption and waste would need to be reduced (e.g. Berg Report, 1981). This came to be known as the Washington Consensus on market-oriented development. This Consensus underpinned the Structural Adjustment programmes aimed at restructuring the economies of lessdeveloped, poorer, countries and setting them on the path of market - led growth. Now we have the post-Washington Consensus; this new ‘consensus’ is a widely-held view that government itself is sometimes not the most efficient way to deliver services, but that the government can help where the services are in any case not delivered by markets. The post-Washington Consensus idea that you intervene “where there is market failure”, also has radical critics (Fine, 2001). This new consensus again has its own particular way of slotting ‘poverty’ and the ‘poor’ into the discourse. Fine explains that to say that the poor lack social capital is to avoid discussing deeper structural class problems. Green argues that there is nothing essential to be seeking, in poverty, but only these twists and turns of social construction of poverty (Green, 2006. As an anthropologist, her view is that poverty is simply socially constructed; my view is that poverty is partly socially constructed but also partly real . Elsewhere, Green offers important advice to those who run goverments, or international institutions.(Green, 2002).. Her advice is to focus on real social differentiation and to avoid glib overview statements when framing policy. This is good advice but does not do justice to the need for a radical overhaul of dominant conceptions of poverty. In fact it seems rather mildly reformist.