Poverty discourse presupposes the position of the speaker – “we” are not “them.” This social inclusion discourse creates social divisions, and patronizes, marginalizes and blames poor people.
Olsen, 2010 - Professor of Socio-Economics, Social Statistics at University of Manchester [Wendy “Poverty as a Malaise of Development: A Discourse Analysis in its Global Context”, https://www.escholar.manchester.ac.uk/api/datastream?publicationPid=uk-ac-man-scw:29857&datastreamId=SUPPLEMENTARY-1.PDF ZR]
Firstly, the speaker who uses the social exclusion/inclusion discourse engages in a contradictory moment, called a ‘performative contradiction’, by excluding the poor from autonomous action. Just by labelling them poor and making ‘them’ a them, and ‘us’ (the experts or the government) an us, the speaker creates a social division that tends to be patronising and disempowering for really poor people. Having a performative contradiction makes it impossible for policies drawn up under this discourse to attack the nerve centres of poverty creation. Instead, the policies are mainly ameliorative. I would go further and argue that ameliorative reforms in capitalism actually help to reproduce poverty and elitism. But this comes from my own position (see conclusion of paper) – instead let’s look more closely at an example to illustrate the performative contradiction. Milcher and Ivanov, 2008, define and discuss social inclusion as follows: Social inclusion is a relatively new concept promoted especially by the European Union (EU). The EU defines social inclusion as “a process which ensures that those at risk of poverty and social exclusion gain the opportunities and resources necessary to participate fully in economic, social and cultural life and to enjoy a standard of living and well-being that is considered normal in the society in which they live”. Thus, social inclusion is understood as both a relative concept where exclusion can only be judged by comparing the circumstances of some individuals (or groups or communities) relative to others . . . and as a normative concept which places emphasis on the individual’s right of “having a life associated with being a member of a community”. In order to achieve these rights, inclusion policies have to address institutional inefficiencies, which derive from exclusionary acts by agents based on power and social attitudes and result in multiple disadvantages based on gender, age, ethnicity, location, economic, education, health status or disability, etc.” (page 1; Milcher and Ivanov did not cite any reference for their quoted phrases) A stronger and more concerted rejection of structuralism in favour of individualistic reductionism is hard to imagine. Yet the rejection is subtly framed, taking the form of a positive statement in favour of human rights and against inefficiency. Who could disagree? The net result is that the discourse tends to leave poor people to blame for their position, and responsible for their own rescue. After all, it is they, not the state that create the inefficiency. They are not in the state that is so inefficient. The essence of the argument is that they are outside of the state. The tone of such writings is patronising and state-ist yet, ironically, (and confusingly) at the same time, liberal in the soft, ‘small,l’ sense of being socially progressive. Whilst progressive, such liberal views do not enable the “poor” to get into policy processes. Instead, they patronise poor people and keeps them separate from the well-educated, technocratic classes.