Focusing on poverty statistics distracts policymakers from seeing the poor as people – focusing on deeper structures is necessary to address exclusion.
Stephens, 2006 – School of Government at Victoria University of Wellington [Robert, 7/26/2006, Ministry of Social Development, “Poverty by Ruth Lister, Polity Press, 2004, The Poverty Wars by Peter Saunders, UNSW Press, 2005” https://www.msd.govt.nz/about-msd-and-our-work/publications-resources/journals-and-magazines/social-policy-journal/spj28/28-poverty-by-ruth-lister-polity-press-2004-the-poverty-wars-by-peter-saunders-unsw-press-2005-p197-199.html, - MZ]
Although this approach takes away the strictures both authors make about the arbitrary nature of most statistical poverty work, their warnings that poverty research must not be confined to ascertaining which groups in society will have a higher incidence of poverty are well made. Statistical measurement concentrates attention on lack of income as the cause of poverty, rather than asking what factors in society lead some individuals or groups to have a lack of income. Debate tends to focus on the level of the poverty standard rather than the factors required for individuals to function in society and achieve their capabilities, and measurement means that the dynamic, multi-dimensional and interactive nature of poverty is overlooked. Both authors want to move the poverty debate forward from income poverty into the analysis of deprivation (along the lines of the Ministry of Social Development’s Living Standards Survey – see Jensen et al. 2003); capability, functioning and social exclusion (see Salmond and Crampton 2001 for a New Zealand forerunner); and poverty dynamics (Ballantyne et al. 2004 provide a New Zealand foretaste). This wider perspective on poverty permits a better analysis of the causes and consequences of poverty and exclusion. Although Saunders is concerned with direct effects such as local labour market failings, or trigger events such as sick children or disability, Lister looks behind those issues in search of even deeper meanings, such as societal structures, denial of participation, infringement of human and citizens rights, and lack of voice and power. She places poverty in the context of socio-economic inequality and social class, and while social exclusion is separate from poverty, it provides a useful lens through which poverty can be analysed. The variables Saunders considers are more amenable to policy than those of Lister, and thus have greater potential for alleviation and amelioration of poverty. However, unless a longer-term strategy is taken to address the concerns that Lister raises, poverty will always be with us. And although local poverty research is moving from statistical measurement and concentration on income poverty into this deeper understanding, New Zealand is still vulnerable to a return to the 1990s when poverty (then known as “the P word”) could not be mentioned in official circles. Poverty became a political issue when the implications for health care outcomes and educational attainment were shown: neither book really spends sufficient space to demonstrate how the issue of poverty can be maintained on the political agenda, especially through the analysis of the consequences of poverty. Instead, Saunders concludes with a request for both a set of inter-related poverty indicators and a European Union commitment to address poverty. In her book, Lister remains above that requirement, knowing that the United Kingdom’s well-respected Child Poverty Action Group will be at the forefront of political advocacy. Instead, she makes us confront our own views and notions of the concepts of poverty, its definitions, measures and causes, so that ultimately the understanding of poverty can lead to the correct explanations and policy prescriptions.