Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The term “Underclass” reinforces the themes of the undeserving poor, of moral weakness, and the division between us and them.

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]

Societal line drawing and moral censure took a brief detour in the 1960s. The "War on Poverty" was the product of a period of unrelenting growth in the gross national product and unbounded optimism about society's ability to abolish poverty without any real sacrifice. 24 During this time, people spoke of the cruel error of assuming a correlation between poverty and moral weakness. 25 As more Americans focused on the eradication of poverty, there was less interest in separating and stigmatizing the poor. Yet, as the "War on Poverty" came unraveled in the wash of blood, here and in Southeast Asia, and as people came to see the actual sacrifice entailed in eliminating poverty, the public discourse soon drifted back to the theme of moral weakness. 26 The rhetoric of poverty in the 1980s was exemplified by the myth of the welfare mother with a Cadillac and by the rise of yet another category of the poor, the "underclass."' 27 This new category of the poor included: (a) the passive poor, usually long-term welfare recipients; (b) the hostile street criminals who terrorize most cities, and who are often school dropouts and drug addicts; (c) the hustlers, who, like street criminals, may not be poor and who earn their livelihood in an underground economy, but rarely commit violent crimes; (d) the traumatized drunks, drifters, homeless shopping-bag ladies and released mental patients who frequently roam or collapse on city streets. 28 Membership in the underclass was determined by behavior which was either patently immoral or socially deviant. The concept of the underclass etched deeper the division between us and them. It also connected perfectly with the rhetorical theme of moral weakness. Except for some examples of the "traumatized" members of the underclass, the behavior that characterized the underclass was criminal, deviant, or that of a person without hope or dignity. The idea of the "passive" poor, people beyond hope and without any sense of initiative, expressed the pervasive notion that poor people were unwilling to pull themselves up by their bootstraps and were instead happy to feed at the public trough.29 The "underclass" thus was a late twentieth century form of the historically persistent category, the undeserving poor. And like its historical antecedents, the idea of the "underclass", seemed to be driven more by ideology than by any attempt accurately to generalize about the circumstances and nature of poverty in America. Michael Katz contrasted the idea of the underclass and the reality: [A]s a metaphor, the underclass obscures more than it reveals. It glosses over differences in condition that require varied forms of help, and it passes lightly over two salient features of poverty and welfare in America: their widespread and transient character. In the Michigan study, which followed a large sample of American families for 10 years.... [b]oth poverty and welfare use .. .lasted relatively briefly, and children whose parents relied on welfare were no more likely to need public assistance as adults than were others in the sample. What the study shows, in short, is that poverty is more accurately perceived now, as before in American history, as a point on a continuum rather than a sharp, clearly demarcated category of social experience. In truth, the forces that push individuals and families into poverty originate in the structure of America's political economy. Some of us are lucky, not different. 30 As a metaphor, the underclass is the perfect expression of the rhetorical themes of difference and deviance. Perhaps because it so perfectly expresses these persistent historical themes, it has remained as part of the public discourse on poverty notwithstanding its metaphoric and distorting quality.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.