Arguing that poverty is inevitable or impossible to solve because “it has always been there” is the rhetoric of helplessness – it is a self fulfilling prophecy because it hides the fact that we have Always had the ability to solve poverty – we Choose not to.
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]
B. OUR HELPLESSNESS The other central theme of the rhetoric of poverty is helplessness. This theme is expressed in two related ways. First, poverty is said to be an inescapable societal tragedy that we are helpless to remedy.3 2 Second, in the legal rhetoric of poverty, judges profess to be helpless in their judicial role. Their helplessness places the particular legal problems related to poverty beyond the perimeters of their power and jurisdiction. Using this rhetoric of helplessness, judges sometimes concede that the problem of poverty may be capable of solution, and then assert that they, however, are not empowered to solve it. They identify someone else, typically the legislature, as the body empowered to address the problem. In cases dealing with poverty, the rhetoric of judicial helplessness sometimes incorporates the idea that poverty is an intractable, if not inevitable, social problem. In this sense of helplessness, the judges are helpless both as individuals (poverty is a complex and intractable problem) and as judges (in any event, we are without the power to deal with this particular issue relating to poverty).33 This sense of helplessness of both judges and the public in the face of poverty has a history that accounts in part for its contemporary presence and rhetorical power. 1. The Helplessness of Those Not in Poverty The idea that poverty in America is inherent or practically irremediable is commonly held today. Expressions like "there have always been poor peo- ple; there always will be poor people" are abundant in our discourse. 34 We bemoan the complex and intractable nature of the problem. Observers often interweave the premise of moral weakness with the argument for the intractable nature of poverty. 35 After all, if poverty is essentially a problem of moral weakness, if poor people must undergo a personal transformation, what can we do to affect such a change? Historically, we have often encouraged such a change on the part of the poor by making the conditions of poverty so appalling that we imagine poor people will do whatever it takes to avoid them.36 We are disappointed when so many poor people seem to insist on not mending their ways and, to our surprise, seem willing to go on living in the horrific conditions of poverty. This disappointment feeds the argument of helplessness. If poor people are unwilling to change their behavior and values in response to the strongest of incentives, the horror of life in poverty, what else can we do? Another version of the argument for helplessness is the characterization of poverty as a product of a mix of abstract forces and ideas, beyond our practical control. Poverty is built into the basic structure of our society, it is a product of our history, traditions, philosophies, political structures, and economic structures.37 Observers who espouse this view of the origins of poverty either see no realistic solution or else see a solution that entails the loss of our most basic social structures.38 This particular profession of helplessness is problematic because poverty arises out of the "politics of distribution.139 Poverty is not a matter of scarcity. We have more than enough to meet the basic needs of everyone in our society, yet we continue to speak about poverty as though it were a problem beyond the reach of our material resources. Perhaps the persistence of poverty leads to the idea that it is inherent in the structure of our society. But all that has ever been required to eliminate poverty is a redistribution of wealth. 4° Although the complex mix of history, traditions, and political structures may help to explain why Americans have chosen not to abolish poverty, it does not explain how that choice is a product of helplessness.