The rhetoric of helplessness obscures the fact that the existence of poverty is a Political Choice, not an inevitability of personal responsibility or vague social forces. Poverty exists because we Choose to all it.
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]
2. Helplessness The contemporary Court's rhetoric of helplessness seeks to move the reader to a position beyond choice. The problem of poverty is presented either as a matter of personal transformation for which we cannot be responsible, or as a matter of such daunting complexity that we cannot solve it. The argument for judicial helplessness is expressed in the oft-repeated litany from Dandidge, the problem of poverty is "not the business of this Court."205 This profession of helplessness in the rhetoric of poverty is both revealing and obscuring. The "personal transformation" argument reveals the problem of individual responsibility in the matter of poverty. Some people do remain poor, in part, because they lack the will to change. The "too many forces" argument reveals the power of history and tradition. When generations of Americans have grown up with poverty as an enduring feature of the cultural landscape, the assumption that poverty is built into our society becomes difficult to change. In the process of revealing these features of poverty, however, the helplessness argument obscures another view of poverty. When Americans talk about poverty, some things remain unsaid. Mainstream discourse about poverty, whether liberal or conservative, largely stays silent about politics, power, and equality. But poverty, after all, is about distribution; it results because some people receive a great deal less than others. Descriptions of the demography, behavior, or beliefs of subpopulations cannot explain the patterned inequalities evident in every era of American history. These result from styles of dominance, the way power is exercised, and the politics of distribution. Poverty no longer is natural; it is a social product. As nations emerge from the tyranny of subsistence, gain control over the production of wealth, develop the ability to feed their citizens and generate surpluses, poverty becomes not the product of scarcity, but of political economy. Yet with few exceptions (such as some of the discussions during the Great Depression of the 1930s or the internal colonialism debate of the 1960s), this is not the way Americans have talked and written about poverty.2°6 This view of poverty reveals the fact that the existence of poverty involves an element of choice on our part.