The Affirmative treats persons in poverty differently – this undermines the respect and recognition that they deserve
Lister, 2005 – Professor of Social Policy Loughborough University [Ruth Jan 2005, “Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect” https://www.bevanfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Ruth-Lister-2004.pdf, EH]
The ‘politics of recognition’ is typically linked with the assertion of group difference and identity – by women, lesbians and gays, BME groups, disabled people. People in poverty do not want to be treated as different – indeed that’s the last thing they want. Instead their struggle is for recognition of their common humanity and citizenship and the equal worth that flows from that. But as we have seen, nonrecognition and disrespect are all too often the experience of people in poverty. Their struggle for voice is very much a politics of recognition. But, in order to reflect the language used by people in poverty themselves, I have called it a ‘politics of recognition and respect’. The philosophy behind it is summed up beautifully in an article in the Bevan Foundation Review by one of your trustees, Kevin Fitzpatrick: Equality of treatment, equality of outcome, depends crucially on everyone respecting everyone else just because they are human. This respect has to be recognised publicly and must be demonstrated by our institutions and the way they behave…To be treated as a human being is to be given the respect and dignity everyone deserves just because they are human (2003: 7). Fraser contends that the struggle for social justice requires the integration of a politics of redistribution and recognition. My own analysis of poverty leads to the same conclusion. Policy reform has to be directed towards tackling the material manifestations of poverty and ultimately its eradication. But so long as there are people living in poverty it must also address their lack of voice and the way in which they are treated by public institutions. In other words it must be informed by principles of equal citizenship.