Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Our discourse defines us – how we talk about the poor demonstrates how we perceive ourselves – the rhetoric of poverty is as much about our superiority as it is about the inferiority of “the poor.”

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]

Part II of this article is an exploration of the historical and cultural standing of these rhetorical themes. Part III is a demonstration of the presence and persistence of this rhetoric in the contemporary Court's opinions. Part IV is a consideration of the power of this rhetoric and the resulting responsibility of the reader. In a world in which silence is sometimes the most powerful moral statement one can make, no one can read the opinions that constitute our contemporary constitutional jurisprudence of poverty and thereafter find a morally neutral position. To the extent we are influenced by the Court's rhetoric, we need to understand the process by which we are influenced. We need to realize that how we talk and argue about poverty reveals what we believe about ourselves and others. II. THE RHETORIC OF POVERTY Rhetoric is built from the cultural assumptions and attitudes available to its creator.7 The contemporary legal rhetoric of poverty is built on premises that have both a validity in the contemporary culture and a history of their own. The premise of the moral weakness of the poor has been around in various forms throughout our history. Likewise, the argument that we are all helpless to change the harsh reality of the poor has a long lineage in American public discourse. And the particular argument of judicial helplessness has served as the rhetorical linchpin for important legal issues throughout our history.8 To understand the nature and power of the contemporary legal rhetoric of poverty requires some understanding of the history and cultural standing of its basic premises. A. THE IMMORALITY OF THE POOR The separation and stigmatization of people in poverty is not new. In vari- ous manifestations, it has been a constant feature of our culture.9 In fact, the cultural separation and stigmatization of the poor has been a feature of most Western cultures throughout modem history.10 In one fashion or another the poor have always been separated by class distinctions and labels. They have been labeled "paupers," "peasants," and "strangers." They have been cast as different, deviant, and morally weak. 1 These assumptions make coherent the physical separation of the poor from the affluent. Just as the separation and stigmatization of the poor is a recurring cultural assumption, the intensified suffering of those in poverty in times of natural or man-made disaster has been a recurring societal reality. During the great plagues of Europe, for example, the poor were left in what became ghettos of disease and death while the affluent left for enclaves outside the cities. 12 As a result, the plagues took the lives of a much larger percentage of the poor. Famine, wars, and natural disasters have followed a similar pattern, with the burdens falling disproportionately on the poor.1 3 The cultural assumptions and the societal realities cannot be disconnected. The assumptions make the disproportionate suffering coherent.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.