Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The rhetoric of poverty creates an us/them dichotomy, which reinforces the segregation of people labeled as morally weak. Those distinctions have been proven wrong.

Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]

1. Conceptual Segregation and Moral Weakness The Court's rhetoric of poverty has conceptually segregated the poor in various ways. When Justice Stewart, in Dandridge, demanded an "equitable balance" between the "families on welfare and those supported by an employed breadwinner," he conceptually separated those families in poverty and receiving public assistance from other families. In his validation of the Texas AFDC scheme in Jefferson, Justice Rehnquist separated AFDC recipients into the undeserving, able-bodied poor, and the deserving, disabled and aged poor. Running through the cases analyzed in Part III, particularly those dealing with disability benefits and food stamps, is the specter of fraud, which in turn depends on the segregation of recipients of public assistance into a group especially likely to deceive. The very act of conceptual segregation has rhetorical power. When the members of the segregated group are defined by their difference from those in a dominant position in society, the very act of segregation suggests not simply difference but also deviance. 197 The norm is defined by the dominant group; the segregated group is defined by deviance from that norm. The power of this segregation is vividly revealed in the rhetoric of poverty. The rhetoric of poverty reiterates this label of deviance through the varitural ous expressions of the moral weakness of the poor. For example, when Justice Blackmun portrayed the AFDC mother in Wyman as the likely perpetrator of child neglect and abuse, the reader is willing to accept this characterization partly because of the conceptual segregation of the AFDC mother. 98 The segregation of the poor and the assertion of their moral deviance are intertwined. Accepting the us/them construct makes the assertion of moral deviance easier to accept, and, reciprocally, the acceptance of the construct of moral deviance reinforces the idea of difference. If we had no conception of difference--if AFDC mothers were not thought of as a category distinct from mothers in general-the assertion of moral deviance would be disturbing because it would be an assertion about us and our families. While we cannot think of ourselves as so prone to child abuse that home visits by government agents are appropriate in the absence of probable cause, we can think of others in that way. Thus, the two rhetorical themes work together, iterating and reiterating the essential message that the poor are different and deviant. In its assertion or suggestion of the difference and deviance of the poor, the rhetoric of poverty is both revealing and obscuring. The rhetoric reveals the reality of criminal and immoral behavior among the poor. The rich are not the only ones who defraud the government and abuse their children. At the same time, the rhetoric of poverty obscures the aspects of poverty that reflect our own lives. The lives of the poor have always mirrored the lives of the rest of society. Many of us struggle to raise children and to find and do work. We all feel humiliation and have aspirations. We all face desperate moral choices of one sort or another; we all succumb to temptation or despair at one time or another; we all, at the end, have good reason to question the strength of our individual will.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.