Our ethical duty is to expose and denounce the rhetoric of poverty as a rhetoric of difference and indifference. Each time we hear or read the speech act, our silence empowers the continued stigmatization and influences our own perspectives.
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]
IV. THE POWER OF RHETORIC-THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE READER The contemporary Court, in a range of cases dealing with the rights and interests of the poor, has adopted a non-interventionist approach. The Court has left the law's treatment of people in poverty largely to the political processes, acknowledging only the narrowest constitutional grounds for addressing their interests. The Justices have put forth opinions abundant with both explicit and, more often, implicit assumptions of the difference and moral weakness of the poor. Repeatedly, the Justices have stressed their own helplessness to correct the problems of poverty. This pattern of choice and rhetoric provides a structure for understanding the power of rhetoric. Out of an understanding of the nature of the rhetoric of poverty emerges a responsibility, an ethic, incumbent on the reader. As we read the Court's opinions embodying the rhetoric of poverty we are engaged in an activity with moral connotations. Once we have read the opinions, there is no morally neutral position available-we must act as critics. Here, even silence is a morally charged position. We, as readers, have a responsibility to resist the rhetorician's magic and to see the subject of our inquiry as clearly and fully as possible. The essential points of this part of the article have relevance beyond the bounds of the poverty cases. Each case we read, whatever its subject, represents a choice imposed on other people backed by the threat or actuality of violence.1 92 It may be a choice to terminate a woman's relationship with her son, to send a man to death or to a cage for the rest of his life, or to allow the carnage of an undeclared war to continue. Whatever the subject of the case, we cannot escape our responsibility as readers. The Court's jurisprudence of poverty is nevertheless a sensible place to begin for two reasons. First, there is so much at stake in this area. Critical inquiry into the constitutional status of poverty is needed from as many thoughtful and responsible vantage points as possible. These cases are about our obligation to those members of our society who lack the very means of subsistence. Second, the rhetoric of poverty is an especially illuminating example of the complex and indirect power of rhetoric. These cases provide a great lesson in reading. A. THE POWER OF RHETORIC The analysis of judicial rhetoric is an exploration of the human activity of reading. This activity is at once both simple to describe and difficult to understand. 1 93 How the reader derives meaning from text is hard to say, and how that meaning influences the reader in her understanding of the constitutional issues of poverty is unclear. Surely, many who read the judicial rhetoric of poverty are influenced by it. Although rhetoric rarely changes the reader's mind, it often subtly influences people by either creating doubt or strengthening resolve. When the Justices repeat the argument of judicial helplessness in case after case, the reader may begin to wonder whether there truly is any choice in the matter. When the reader is repeatedly confronted with the conceptual segregation of the poor, she is more likely to accept some version of the us/them idea embedded in this rhetoric. Our own experiences of reading judicial rhetoric tell us that these sorts of effects do occur. What we need to understand is how this happens to us.