We focus on the true Structural causes of poverty – the lack of decent jobs – rather than blaming the poor themselves. Hirschl et al, 2003 - Professor of Global Development at Cornell University [Thomas with Mark R. Rank and Hong-Sik Yoon December, The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare “American poverty as a structural failing: evidence and arguments” https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2936&context=jssw ZR]
Three lines of evidence are detailed in order to illustrate the structural nature of poverty--1) the inability of the U.S. labor market to provide enough decent paying jobs for all families to avoid poverty or near poverty; 2) the ineffectiveness of American social policy to reduce levels of poverty through governmental social safety net programs; and 3) the fact that the majority of the population will experience poverty during their adult lifetimes, indicative of the systemic nature of U.S. poverty. Each of these lines of evidence are intended to empirically illustrate that American poverty is by and large the result of structural failures and processes. The Inability of the Labor Market to Support All Families Several of the pioneering large scale studies of poverty conducted at the end of the 19'th and beginning of the 20'th century focused heavily on the importance of labor market failings to explain poverty. The work of Charles Booth (1892-1897), Seebohm Rowntree (1901), Hull House (1895), Robert Hunter (1904), and W. E. B. DuBois (1899) all emphasized the importance of inadequate wages, lack of jobs, and unstable working conditions as a primary cause of poverty. For example, Rowntree (1901) estimated that approximately 57 percent of individuals in poverty were there as a direct result of labor market failures (low wages, unemployment, irregularity of work). Yet by the 1960's the emphasis had shifted from a critique of the economic structure as a primary cause of poverty, to an analysis of individual deficiencies (e.g., the lack of human capital) as the underlying reason for poverty. As Timothy Bartik (2001) notes, U.S. antipoverty policy has focused heavily on labor supply policies (e.g. increasing individual's human capital or incentives to work through welfare reform) rather than labor demand policies (increasing the number and quality of jobs). As mentioned earlier, social scientific research has reinforced this policy approach by focusing on individual deficiencies to explain individual poverty. Yet it can be demonstrated that irrespective of the specific characteristics that Americans possess, there simply are not enough decent paying jobs to support all of those (and their families) who are looking for work. During the past 25 years the American economy has increasingly produced larger numbers of low paying jobs, jobs that are part-time, and jobs that are lacking in benefits (Seccombe, 2000). For example, the Census Bureau estimated that the median hourly earning of workers who were paid hourly wages in 2000 was $9.91, while at the same time approximately three million Americans were working part-time as a result of the lack of sufficient full-time work being available (U.S. Census Bureau, 2001). In addition, 43.6 million Americans were lacking in health insurance, largely because their employer did not provide such benefits (U.S. Census Bureau, 2003b). Poverty is not the result of individual choices – social structures determine inequality.
Pineda, 2021 - Managing Consultant at Esploro Company [Mathew, September 19, Profolus, “Theories of Poverty”, ZR]
In his book, political science professor David Brady argues that poverty is not simply a result of the inability of an individual. Poverty tends to be prevalent in vulnerable demographic environments and troubled labor market circumstances. Hence, the greater the number of people living under these circumstances, the higher the prevalence of poverty. Brady specifically explains that poverty results from the failure of the society to collectively take responsibility for promoting the economic security of its citizens through the instrument of the welfare state. Hence, welfare programs are collectively the best tool for reducing poverty. Sociology professor Edward Royce also argues that in the United States, despite being a rich country, poverty remains rampant not because of the individual failings of the poor but because of the failings of the American social system, especially of its political economy. Royce specifically noted that poverty represents structural inequality. In societies with incidents of poverty, people have unequal status as demonstrated in unequal relations in roles, functions, decisions, rights, and opportunities.