Allowing poverty and suffering to continue is a Choice. Their rhetoric hides and obscures that choice, making it easier to accept suffering.
Ross, 1991 Prof. of Law at the University of Pittsburgh [Thomas, June Georgetown Law Review “The Rhetoric of Poverty: Their Immorality, Our Helplessness”, https://heinonline-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/glj79&id=1517&type=text&collection=journals, MZ]
V. CONCLUSION The question posed by this article is where will we choose to stand on the rhetorical field. As readers and critics within the legal community, we have an ethical obligation to ponder and choose our perspective. The Court's rhetoric of poverty has provided a ready viewing point on the legal issues of poverty. It is a relatively comfortable niche-either a place beyond choice or a seat of judgment from which we see the poor and judge their moral strength, winnowing out the undeserving from the deserving poor. There are other viewing points we might choose, however. We might choose to acknowledge the inherent element of our own choice in these matters and our responsibility for that choice. We might choose to struggle to see their suffering as ours. We might choose to question our own moral strengths and weaknesses. From these other, less comfortable, viewing points we may still see the Court's choices as right. But to do so we would have to accept that suffering which might have been alleviated was not, not because we were beyond choice in the matter, but rather because we made the hardest choice that life puts to us-the choice that suffering we might relieve ought nonetheless continue. The rhetoric of poverty shelters us from our choices. The rhetoric allows us to imagine that the suffering of the poor is just or that we are helpless to end it. But our legal history is replete with the most elegant rhetorical facades built around the most horrific of legal choices.212 And we must wonder whether our legal choices about poverty will bring upon us and our chil- dren the tragedy and shame that historically have attended those who take the shelter of rhetoric in a storm of human suffering.