Our alternative is a social justice perspective of poverty, which rehumanizes people labeled as “the poor” and accounts for race and gender along with class.
Lister 2004 - Professor of Social Policy, Loughborough University [Ruth Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect https://www.bevanfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Ruth-Lister-2004.pdf EV]
A social justice perspective on poverty means considering it in relation to the overall distribution of income and wealth. As one writer on social justice put it, ‘we are discussing how the good and bad things in life should be distributed among the members of a human society’ (Miller, 1999: 1). Or, in the immortal words of R. H. Tawney, ‘what thoughtful rich people call the problem of poverty thoughtful poor people call with equal justice the problem of riches’ (1913). For much of the twentieth century the trend was towards a more equitable distribution of material resources. The trend halted after 1979 and went into reverse; the share of income (both before and after tax) received by the top 1 per cent has returned to broadly similar levels to those when Nye Bevan was a government minister in the 1940s (Atkinson, 2003). According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies, the present government has not been able to bring inequality down to earlier levels but its more redistributive measures have at least helped to stem the rate of the upwards trend. A social justice perspective on poverty means considering it in relation to the overall distribution of income and wealth. While my focus is on poverty and social justice in Britain, Bevan’s internationalism, reflected in the ethos of the Foundation, means that we must not forget global inequality. Although global trends are the subject of some dispute, many argue that an intensification of poverty in some countries is associated with growing global inequality, the level of which has been described by the United Nations Development Programme as ‘grotesque’ (2003: 39). 7 Throughout the world, poverty intersects with social divisions of gender, ‘race’ and disability and also with position in the life-course (with childhood and old age particularly vulnerable stages in many countries). Thus, it can reflect not just class-related inequalities but also discriminatory processes that disadvantage women, black and minority ethnic (BME) groups and disabled people. In the UK, it has been estimated that women are five per cent more likely than men to be in poverty (Bradshaw et al., 2003). But the statistics do not tell us the full extent of female poverty because they assume that resources are shared fairly within the family, an assumption questioned by a number of studies. Moreover, as an Oxfam GB study in Merthyr Tydfil demonstrated, a gender analysis deepens our understanding of the different ways that men and women experience poverty (Buhaenko et al., 2003). The presence of a disabled adult or child increases the risk of poverty by seven to eight percentage points. Black and minority ethnic groups are more likely overall to be in poverty than white groups. There is, however, considerable diversity between minority ethnic groups. The greatest deprivation is among Pakistanis and Bangladeshis, seven out of ten of whom are in poverty. Although they are not picked up by the statistics, some of the worst poverty is to be found among asylum-seekers. The work of the Refugee Council suggests that the operation of section 55 has left some asylum-seekers destitute, reliant on the support of voluntary organisations and refugee communities.