We need a new definition of poverty – our alternative sees the social and representational aspects of poverty, not just the material conditions.
Lister 2004 - Professor of Social Policy, Loughborough University [Ruth Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect https://www.bevanfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Ruth-Lister-2004.pdf EV]
What do we mean by poverty? I am conscious that I have been talking about poverty without defining my terms. The figures I have given you are based on the measure used by government that is most frequently cited: 60 per cent of median income, after housing costs. This is sometimes erroneously called a definition of poverty, but it is no such thing. It is simply a measure and measures are technical devices that are constrained by limitations of methodology and by the available data. A definition should distinguish the state of poverty from that of non-poverty, for instance in terms of low living standards and/or inability to participate fully in society because of lack of material resources. Such a definition is reflected in some of the ways that people in poverty themselves talk about poverty, for instance: ‘Sleeping in a bed that used to be someone’s else’s, wearing cast-off clothes, and being expected to be grateful’; or ‘Dreading every Christmas and birthday because of the disappointment in the children’s eyes’ (ATD u.d.). But listening to people in poverty also reveals other meanings – words like ‘humiliating’, ‘indignity’, ‘denial of human rights’ (UKCAP, 1997). People talk about feeling judged and looked down on; ‘never feeling good enough’ (ATD u.d.). 8 This suggests that as well as measures and definitions, we need a broader conceptualisation of poverty if we are to understand its meanings, particularly for those experiencing it. A broader conceptualisation of poverty enables us to take on board its non-material aspects. These largely stem from people in poverty’s everyday interactions with the wider society and from the way they are talked about and treated by politicians, officials, professionals, the media. Poverty has to be understood not just as a disadvantaged and insecure economic condition but also as a shameful and corrosive social relation. This perspective has been illuminated in particular by participatory research in the Southern hemisphere. This has highlighted non-material aspects of poverty such as: lack of voice, disrespect, humiliation and an assault on dignity and self-esteem, shame and stigma; powerlessness; denial of rights and diminished citizenship. I will elaborate on some of these in a moment. Poverty has to be understood as a shameful and corrosive social relation.