Only the affirmative can alleviate poverty – we need to focus on policy implementation details and poverty measurements to reduce labelling and stigmatization
Stephens, 2006 – School of Government at Victoria University of Wellington [Robert, 7/26/2006, Ministry of Social Development, “Poverty by Ruth Lister, Polity Press, 2004, The Poverty Wars by Peter Saunders, UNSW Press, 2005” https://www.msd.govt.nz/about-msd-and-our-work/publications-resources/journals-and-magazines/social-policy-journal/spj28/28-poverty-by-ruth-lister-polity-press-2004-the-poverty-wars-by-peter-saunders-unsw-press-2005-p197-199.html, - MZ]
The approaches taken by the authors reflect the current state of the debate on poverty within their respective countries. In Australia, Peter Saunders’s namesake and nemesis at the neoliberal Centre for Independent Studies (CIS) seems to have captured the media and political debate, disputing that the existence of poverty is anything other than a failure by the poor themselves, abetted by overgenerous welfare state programmes. This approach seems reminiscent of New Zealand during the 1990s. In the United Kingdom, poverty and its alleviation are centre stage for the Blair government, and while there may be debates over causes and cures, the acceptance of the concept of poverty allows Lister time to explore its deeper meanings and implications rather than ensuring poverty remains on the political agenda. She has the luxury of being able to explore the debates as to whether poverty is caused by individual traits or better explained by societal/ structuralist concepts of class, gender, race, geography and disability. Her discussion on discourses such as othering (“the labelling and stigmatizing of marginalized social groups”) and social exclusion (which underpins the causes of social dynamics) provide the antidote to the CIS-based Peter Saunders and, when combined with discussion on human rights and citizenship, shows the need “to embed anti-poverty policies within wider policy debates” of a general social inclusion strategy. When the academic Peter Saunders changes tack from an advocate to a researcher, his coverage of topics overlaps with those of Lister, though at the more intuitive level suitable for the intended audience of those in the front line of anti-poverty policy development and implementation. Lister’s book is far more academic, but essential reading for those in government departments dealing with issues of social development and exclusion, and also for notions of integrated and coordinated policy formulation. Both authors argue that for poverty research to be creditable it has to be grounded in the experiences of the poor, and commensurate with community values and norms, and both draw on the qualitative experiences of the poor to support their claims. However, measurement of the extent and severity of poverty is the first element in the development of anti-poverty policies, requiring the setting of a poverty standard. Here it is a pity that neither author drew on the work of the New Zealand Poverty Measurement Project (Stephens et al. 1995, Waldegrave et al. 1996), because their use of focus groups provided a method for integrating household experience of surviving on low incomes with a quantitative poverty standard.