Attempts to include poor peoples’ voices do not increase their participation – they have been false promises and short term projects.
Lister, 2005 – Professor of Social Policy Loughborough University [Ruth Jan 2005, “Poverty and Social Justice: recognition and respect” https://www.bevanfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Ruth-Lister-2004.pdf, EH]
There is now acceptance in government of the principle that disadvantaged groups should have a say in decision-making that affects their lives. Here in Wales, the principle informs the Communities First programme – how successfully I do not know and I hope some of you might be able to comment on this. In England, it has likewise been central to the philosophy of the New Deal for Communities and the National Strategy for Neighbourhood Renewal. However, as John Gaventa of the Institute for Development Studies has warned, the growing acceptance of the principle of participation does not necessarily translate into ‘voice with influence’ (2002). Oxfam GB (2004) writes that, despite the progress that has been made, ‘people in poverty (and/or in disadvantaged communities) are still systematically excluded from key decisions affecting their lives’. Part of the problem, it identifies, is that centrally imposed targets can undermine genuine local involvement so that local people have no real power. Moreover, all too often involvement in community regeneration programmes is rushed and limited to superficial consultation, without any feedback to the people who have given their time to the exercise. This often reflects a tension between the understandable desire for quick gains and the need for time to do the necessary community development work to make a reality of community involvement. This is sometimes called building community capacity. But there is also a need to build capacity among officials and professionals to engage in this way of working. A rare acknowledgement of this can be found in the recent Home Office report, Building Civil Renewal. As Oxfam GB (2004) writes: it is vital to shift the ideas and beliefs of service delivers and decisionmakers towards people in poverty, so that the latter are treated with the same respect that any other citizen feels entitled to – failure to do so is a recipe for continuing alienation from government and its efforts. Unless decision-makers have the political will and mechanisms to really listen to what women and men in disadvantaged communities are saying about the barriers that face them, long-term solutions will continue to be elusive. One of the clear messages received by the Commission on Poverty, Participation and Power (2000) was that ‘people experiencing poverty see consultation without commitment, and phoney participation without the power to bring about change, as the ultimate disrespect’. A similar message is reported in the Foundation’s report on the South Wales Valleys: ‘So many people have told us that they were weary of repeatedly being asked for their views but nothing happening. People…want to see action on the ground, and evidence that they are respected and valued’ (Winckler, 2003, p42).