Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A basic income with automation will not reduce inequality because it will occur within the capitalist system

Scheidel 2018 - professor of humanities and history at Stanford University, [Walter Scheidel, September 10, 2018 “Can inequality only be fixed by war, revolution, or plague?”, The Economist, https://www.economist.com/open-future/2018/09/10/can-inequality-only-be-fixed-by-war-revolution-or-plague, ZR]

Walter Scheidel: No, but we need to appreciate that measures that worked well in the past may have done so because they were taken in the unique context of massive violent shocks and threats: the world wars and communism. This requires us to be more creative in dealing with inequality. Above all we must think harder about feasibility. It is not enough for economists to come up with recipes to reduce inequality, we also need to figure out how to implement them in an environment that is politically polarised and economically globalised. Both factors limit our scope for intervention. The Economist: How do artificial intelligence and automation fit in to your thinking? Will they be a calamity for employment and thus for equality? Or might they unleash extraordinary productivity and improvements in living standards that actually narrow inequality? Ideally we would like education to keep up with technological change to make sure workers have the skills they need to face this challenge. But in practice there will always be losers, and even basic-income schemes can take us only so far. At the end of the day, someone owns the robots. As long as the capitalist world system is in place, it is hard to see how even huge productivity gains from greater automation would benefit society evenly instead of funneling even more income and wealth to those who are in the best position to pocket these gains.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.