Rejection of biopolitics and movement towards neoliberalism allows us to move from societies to communities wherein the subjects of government are understood as individuals with identity, able to form their own sets of beliefs, values, and commitments.
Sörensen 2012- Associate Professor and Senior Lecturer in the School of Global Studies, Gothenburg University [Jens Stilhoff, Development Dialogue, April “The Failure of Statebuilding – Changing Biopolitics and the Splintering of Societies” IV, https://www.academia.edu/27448172/The_Failure_of_Statebuilding]
But the modernist project and its inherent universalism was also challenged on other grounds, notably from the left, from perspectives such as postmodernism, multiculturalism, feminism and sustainable development philosophy. In their effect these either share premises with neoliberalism or contain premises which neoliberalism has had a tremendous capacity to appropriate. Just as with neoliberalism, they all concern a new way of conceptualising the plane of reference for government, its objects, subjects, targets and mechanisms. Nicholas Rose has argued that we see a ‘detotalisation’ of society where the thought-space of the social is fragmented. It is fragmented in terms of multiculturalism, and in political controversies over the implications of pluralism, of ethnicity, religion, sexuality, ability and disability, together with conflict over the competing and mutually exclusive ‘rights’ and ‘values’ of diferent communities (Rose 1999: 135). The subjects of government are now understood as individuals with ‘identities’, which not only identify them, but do so through their allegiance to a particular set of community values, beliefs and commitments (Rose 1999: 135). Here, ‘community’ emerges as the ideal territory for the administration of individual and collective, argues Rose, and individual conduct no longer appears ‘socially determined’ but shaped by values that arise from ties of community identification (p 136). We thereby have a replacement of ‘society’ with ‘community’, or ‘communities’. This form of social breakdown is quite compatible with neoliberalism and implies a similar break with aggregate biopolitics. A shifting plane of reference on the part of government towards ‘civil society’ or ‘community’ constitutes no threat to neoliberal thought, and these can both be exposed to market logic and ideas of self-reliance. But community, like society, is not a natural formation; it has to be constructed. The new correlate of government is mapped out, its distinctions and borders defined, and its interests and values identified. Society does not disappear in this process, but it is reworked through new categories that regenerate – or threaten – it. In Western societies the new conceptualisation is exemplified in concerns related to minority communities, 56 Development Dialogue April 2012 – The End of the Development-Security Nexus? gender equality, specific community programmes and afirmative action. This entails a biopolitical separation that is mirrored in international development and security policy. In the global periphery liberalism rediscovers multi-ethnic post-conflict societies as tribal, communal and sectarian, features, which are not merely discovered and addressed but re-generated as a necessary correlate of government in the new kind of governmental rationality. As David Campbell has argued, liberal governance and ethnic national leaders have come to share a common ‘ethnic cartography’ (Campbell 1999). Campbell’s reference was to Bosnia-Herzegovina, but an extreme illustration would be the US counter-insurgency strategy in Iraq, especially from 2007 onwards. Following the complete breakdown of the Iraqi state under the US occupation from 2003, Iraqi society was rapidly divided and mobilised along its ethnic-religious fault lines. Resistance blended with civil war and the ethnoplural city of Baghdad became increasingly ethnically divided (Gregory 2008). The US counterinsurgency strategy popularly called ‘the Surge’ emphasised these divisions. Violence diminished only after a reduction of inter-ethnic contact surfaces, through segregation, walled-of neighbourhoods, and pay-outs to tribal leaders who mobilised their respective followers. The shared ‘ethnic cartography’ reflected biopolitical control measures that operated along ethnic-religious fault lines (Gregory 2008).