Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The Green New Deal still engages with biopolitics but hides it using “green capitalism” to obscure its control. That makes it harder to resist biopolitics and neoliberal climate change

Luke ’09

(Timothy, university distinguished professor of  in the College of Liberal Arts and Human Sciences at , 11/30/09, , “A green new deal: why green, how new, and what is the deal?”, Taylor and Francis Online // AM)

While a backlash against neoliberalism reverberates in these plans, some neoliberal articles of faith remain. Indeed, the superstructure of the Green New Deal rests upon many foundational bases, and one of the deepest is ‘natural capitalism’. Developing more or less alongside the maturation of the Whole Earth Catalogue generation since 1968, the natural capitalism school provides an allegedly radical new vision of practicing local and global exchange by keeping ‘the environment’ as well as ‘the economy’ equally in mind in the marketplace (Hawken et al. ). Natural capitalism is suspicious of concentrated state power, and not entirely comfortable with the technocratic flavor of ecomodernization, but its devotees realize it needs both as political allies. Working together, green capitalists supposedly will turn to the smaller scale, fast-reacting, and broadly engaged responses of business enterprises eager to leverage the full-spectrum of pressing environmental problems as new market-building opportunities in full accord with the world's actually existing capitalist economies (Nordhaus and Shellenberger ). Natural capitalists reimagine the market and its complex division of labor as an allegedly underleveraged natural asset. The use of Nature as a capitalist tool has been stymied during the twentieth century by short-sightedness, greed, and waste as the big business practices of concentrated ownership, planned obsolescence, huge profits, and rapid return-on-investment distorted the traditions of commercial probity and rationality cherished by natural capitalists. Consequently, proponents of natural capitalism, like Paul Hawken, Amory Lovins, Hunter Lovins or Ernest von Weizacker, reimagine the Earth itself as a complex economy rather than a primitive wilderness. The environment is not merely a site; it is an entrenched operational assemblage with an elaborate system of services that fundamentally must be reimagined in terms of cost, benefit, asset, liability, gain, loss and value. Business and environment are not opposing forces; instead they are all of one piece. In fact, the new business model is Nature itself. This article of natural capitalist faith really has taken root. Over the past twenty years, one sees the adoption, cooptation or mobilization of green affect, care or sensibilities in the ordinary conduct of everyday life itself. Whether it is in the realm of architecture, construction, design, farming, gardening, housing, clothing, management, planning, religion, technology, or urbanism, green business thinking has evolved into a fascinating regimen of everyday environmentality (Luke , ) that nests in the thinking and practices of producers, consumers, savers, commuters or everyday actors going about the conduct of their everyday biopolitical existence. Echoes of natural capitalism reverberate constantly through everyday environmentality, and this conceptual mobilization bears traces of the radical changes being made possible in human relationships with the non-human natural world by reimagining some ordinary factors of human life in the transformative terms of green consumerism (von Weizacker et al. ). Much of this spirit also is caught in the ads for a transnational energy corporation like British Petroleum (BP), using bright clean green and yellow product marketing pitches centered on sunflower images to reimagine its growing sales of fossil fuel-derived energy goods and services in an ecological life ‘beyond petroleum’. Other qualities of everyday environmentality surface in widely available chapbooks for living more ecological lives tied to green activism, green commercialism, green consumerism, green residentialism or green suburbanism. Such entrepreneurial-enablements for personal green new dealing truly do believe everyday green agency pursued for its own sake through the search for ‘everyday low prices’ will transform selves and societies. The green new deals, in turn, will materialize society-wide out of the green dimensions found in saving energy, resources, and money. The most thoroughgoing vision of everyday environmentality is mapped out by the ‘c2c’, or ‘cradle to cradle’, green design philosophy of the architects William McDonough and Michael Braungart. In Cradle to Cradle: Remaking the Way We Make Things (McDonough and Braungart ), they offer new administrative design,

manufacturing, and technological alternatives to the flawed material metabolism of the Industrial Revolution, which rests on ‘a take, make, waste’ cycle of economy. Rooted in ‘The Hannover Principles’ for sustainable design as propounded by McDonough and others in the early 1990s (McDonough ), the old ‘cradle to grave’ vision of early industrial resource exhaustion needs to stop such natural capital misuse as an inefficient, open, and unstable system for living. The ‘cradle to cradle’ model finds closed loops of energy, material, information, and labor flows that eliminate waste by turning it into ‘nutrients’ for other energy, material, information and labor systems in a new industrial revolution tied to continuous resource renewal. Ultimately, this discipline for the conduct of everyday life through design is rooted in the traditional truisms of primitive accumulation as ‘waste not, want not’ reworks every facet of contemporary economic exchange. Rather than ecomodernization, this strategy is essentially a bioeconomizing redesign of actually existing capitalism via ‘eco-efficiency’. Such continuous resource renewal turns agro-industrial waste into food, energy or material for other industrial systems to the degree that truly substantial waste disappears. With color-coded design protocols, c2c practices burrow through commodity chains in search of greater economy, efficiency, and ecology. Somewhat counter-intuitively, then, ecological scarcity should disappear in the abundance of economic waste. The devotions of reduce, reuse, and recycle are cast as a radical program of transformation such that they ultimately will revalorize consumption as a means to revitalize continuously improved production. From intelligent power grids, green roofs, organic plastics to non-toxic materials, perpetual circulation, and lifecycle design, the vocations of everyday environmentality itself are reimagined as the right path to individual prosperity, environmental health, and social equity. The mission to remake the way we manufacture things, reframe the way things serve people, and reinvent the ways people and things plainly make ecological, economic, and equitable sense. Yet, making these sensible connections ironically press everyday environmentality deeper into the organization of daily conduct (Foucault ).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.