Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The plan is the definition of asserting biopolitical control – it spreads government influence which is tied to biopolitical control further into the private market – historical examples prove this move will steal biopolitical freedom from the worker. Don’t let the aff fool you – capitalism gained control by first taking the body of the employee- the aff mirrors the rise of liberalism – copying the successful capture of society by the liberal order with the goal of re-asserting biopolitical control.

Cook ’15 (Deborah, pHD in philosophy and faculty member at the University of Windsor in Canada, 3/12/15, “Really Existing Socialization and Socialism in Adorno and Foucault”, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/0725513615576132, Sage Journals, // AM)

In a now famous phrase, Foucault declared that the judges of normality are present everywhere (: 304). We now acquire our sense of who and what we are from the norms that these judges impose on us throughout our lives. This self-understanding becomes – in another memorable phrase – the prison of the body (: 30) because disciplinary norms serve as standards against which individuals judge themselves. Under constant surveillance, and the equally constant pressure to conform to disciplinary norms, individuals internalize these norms and become self-normalizing. This self-monitoring and self-correction effectively obviate the need for intensive observation. Since they are made aware that they may be subjected to the normalizing, panoptic gaze anywhere and at any time, individuals now examine and modify their own behaviour so that they will be accepted as ‘normal’, and fit in. In other words, individuals have become the perpetrators of their own subjection.

Foucault argues that disciplinary power was not, in the first instance, under state control; it was not originally the prerogative of the state. To be sure, Western states now deploy disciplinary techniques, especially in their police forces which provide ‘a supervision that seeks ideally to reach the most elementary particle, the most passing phenomenon of the social body’ (: 213–14). However, the disciplinary techniques that are now used by the police in the West first emerged on a ‘micropolitical’ level, in the institutions mentioned above, where power takes direct and strategic hold of bodies in order to alter and adjust them. Only after these techniques had developed and spread were they appropriated by the state. Moreover, Foucault contends that, even as disciplinary techniques were disseminated throughout institutions, the state developed a new, but complementary, type of power, which he calls biopower. Combining with disciplinary power, the biopolitical state eventually adopted neoliberal practices that now chart the treacherous waters between the Scylla of freedom and the Charybdis of security.

Foucault states that disciplinary power was ‘completely bound up with’ the rise of liberalism (: 67) with its ‘freedom of the market, freedom to buy and sell, the free exercise of property rights, freedom of discussion, possible freedom of expression, and so on’ (: 63). This link between disciplinary power and liberalism also suggests that liberalism’s commitment to freedom was Janus-faced from the start. Liberalism has had a ‘productive/destructive’ relation to freedom: it produced freedom, while simultaneously hemming it in with ‘limitations, controls, forms of coercion, and obligations relying on threats, etcetera’ (: 64). So, for example, trade should in principle be free, but it is invariably accompanied by protectionist measures. Freedom in the domestic market is another principle more honoured in the breach owing to anti-monopoly laws and other legislation. And, on the individual level as well, freedom is constrained as disciplinary power comes to the aid of liberalism, revealing its more ominous face. Although he qualified this idea in another set of lectures, Foucault reasserts in The Birth of Biopolitics that disciplinary power is the ‘counterweight and counterpart of different freedoms‘ owing to its technologies of ‘control, constraint, and coercion’ (: 67).

Disciplinary technologies make liberalism’s fear of big government seem completely misplaced. More to be feared are the totalizing tendencies within the liberal economic order itself. For as discipline began to infiltrate social institutions, it not only served as a homogenizing and levelling force within society, but developed highly effective means (in terms of cost, intensity, and scale) for controlling individuals. As a result, modern societies have become ‘carceral’, open air prisons in which the behaviour of everyone is constantly observed, recorded, assessed and corrected in institutions that are now embedded within the state. As the legal power to punish was naturalized, and the technical power to discipline was legalized, law and discipline began to support one another, making it possible ‘to carry out that great “economy” of power whose formula the eighteenth century had sought when the problem of the accumulation and useful administration of people first emerged’ (: 303, trans. mod.).

Tied to the rise of liberalism, disciplinary power was the hidden support of the economic freedoms that liberalism permitted. It ensured that individuals would be both fit for work and politically submissive. It thereby enabled liberalism to observe the ‘internal rule of maximum economy’ (: 318) and minimal government. Today, disciplinary power helps to prop up neoliberalism which (in both its German and American versions) turns the free market economy into the ‘principle, form, and model’ for the state (: 117). Indeed, Foucault stresses the mutually reinforcing dimensions of disciplinary institutions, the biopolitical state, and the capitalist economy when he observes that capitalism

started by socializing a first object, the body, as a factor of productive force, of labor power. Society’s control over individuals was accomplished not only through consciousness or ideology but also in the body and with the body. For capitalist society, it was biopolitics, the biological, the somatic, the corporal, that mattered more than anything else. (2000: 137)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.