The use of biopower to establish an effective governance paradigm during the Covid pandemic through biopolitical tactics of health terror holds larger implications for public policy that attempts to control and regulate the bodily autonomy of individuals.
Sfetcu 2022 [Nicolae, Researcher at The Romanian Academy, November 2022, , “Biopolitics and Geopolitics” IV Romanian Committee for the History and Philosophy of Science and Technology Telework, https://www.telework.ro/en/biopolitics-and-geopolitics/]
It is always dangerous to entrust doctors and scientists with decisions that are ultimately ethical and political. (Dean 2020) In Medicine as Religion, Giorgio Agamben: states (Agamben 2020b) that in the modern West coexist three major belief systems: Christianity, capitalism and science, which sometimes intersect. The novelty consists in the fact that between science and the other two faiths, without noticing, an underground and relentless conflict was triggered, with successful results for science. In science, medicine occupies a special place, being characterized by does not need a special dogma, but is limited to borrowing its fundamental concepts from biology – there is a god or evil principle, namely disease, whose specific agents are bacteria and viruses, and a beneficent god or principle that is not health, but recovery, whose cultic agents are drugs and therapies the phenomenon has become permanent and ubiquitous – it is no longer about taking medication, doctor visits or surgery: all our lives we must worship this cult moment by moment, because the enemy, the virus, is always present and must be fought constantly the practice of worship is no longer free and voluntary – it becomes mandatory from a normative point of view the medical religion has unreservedly taken over the eschatological urgency from Christianity – the medical religion combines the perpetual crisis of capitalism with the Christian idea of an end time like capitalism and unlike Christianity, the medical religion does not offer the prospect of salvation and redemption – recovery is only temporary, as the evil God, the virus, cannot be eliminated once and for all. (Agamben 2020b) Patrick Zylberman described in 2013 the process by which health security becomes an essential part of state and international political strategies, (Flahault et al. 2016) by creating a kind of “health terror” as a tool for governance. Zylberman shows that the apparatus used by the WHO was articulated in three points: 1) the construction, based on a possible risk, of a fictitious scenario that would allow the governance of an extreme situation; 2) adopting the logic of the worst scenario as a regime of political rationality; 3) organizing all citizens in a way that strengthens government institutions, whereby the imposed obligations are presented as evidence of altruism and the citizen no longer has a right to health but is legally obligated to be healthy (biosecurity). Agamben considers, in Biosicurezza, Agamben 2020a) that the emergency situation can allow the design of a governance paradigm whose effectiveness will go beyond any normal form of governance. Thus, biosecurity has already proved capable of causing the absolute cessation of all political activities and all social relations as the maximum form of civic participation. “In question is a whole conception of the destinies of human society from a perspective that, in many respects, seems to have adopted the apocalyptic idea of the end of the world from the religions that are now at their west. After replacing politics with the economy, now, in order to ensure governance, even this must be integrated with the new paradigm of biosecurity, in front of which we will have to sacrifice all other requirements. It is legitimate to ask whether such a society can still be defined as human or whether the loss of sensitive relationships, face, friendship, love, can really be compensated by an abstract and supposedly completely fictitious health security.” (Agamben 2020a)