Increased minimum wage reduces poverty – even those who lose a job will be better off
Acs et al ‘22 [Gregory Acs; Aug 1, 2022; Robert Wood Johnson Foundation; “Exploring the Effects of a $15 an Hour Federal Minimum Wage on Poverty, Earnings, and Net Family Resources”; https://www.rwjf.org/en/insights/our-research/2022/08/exploring-the-effects-of-a-15-an-hour-federal-minimum-wage-on-poverty-earnings-and-net-family-resources.html; CP]
A $15 an hour federal minimum wage in 2022 represents a large increase in the minimum wage in many parts of the US. If the higher minimum wage induced no change in employment, we project the annual family earnings of affected workers would rise by $5,600, and their net resources (considering changes in taxes and public assistance) would rise by $4,200. Poverty as measured by the SPM would fall by 2.4 percentage points and 7.6 million fewer people would be poor. On average, workers from all racial and ethnic backgrounds are projected to see earnings and net resource gains and reduced poverty, and Hispanic workers and their families are projected to see the greatest gains. That likely reflects the fact that, when compared with non-Hispanic affected workers, Hispanic affected workers are more likely to live with other affected workers, meaning more people in those families would see their earnings rise. That such a large increase in the minimum wage would not cause any displacement in the labor market is possible but not probable. When we account for the possibility of job loss by adapting a central finding from the literature on the sensitivity of employment to increases in the minimum wage in our projections, we find that 3.2 million workers will experience a job loss during the year that would otherwise not have occurred. Nevertheless, even accounting for this level of job loss, we project average earnings in families with at least one affected worker would rise by about $5,000, and net resources would rise by more than $3,700. About 6.9 million people would be lifted out of poverty, and the poverty rate would fall by 2.1 percentage points. Considerable debate and uncertainty exist about the sensitivity of employment to the minimum wage. If employment is more sensitive than we have allowed for in our projections, job losses would be higher and income gains would be lower. In projections not shown in detail here, we find that if employment was roughly twice as sensitive to the minimum wage as we have assumed in our projections allowing for job loss, about 5.5 million workers would experience a job loss they otherwise would not have at some point during the year, but 6.3 million fewer people would be poor, and the poverty rate would be 2.0 percentage points lower than without the increase in the minimum wage. 2 6 EXPLORING THE EFFECTS OF A $15 AN HOUR FEDERAL MINIMUM WAGE Our approach to projecting the impacts of raising the minimum wage draws on the frameworks used by CBO (2019) and NAS (2019) but with some notable differences. Rather than considering job loss in a given week or month, we focus on the number of workers who would experience job loss they otherwise would not have at any point during a year. Looking over a year window allows more workers to experience a job loss, so our overall job-loss projections will be higher than those from snapshot analyses. But we also allow workers projected to lose a job in one month to regain employment in some future month. Although some workers may end up working less time during the year, they will be paid more for the time they do work. In addition, we consider a larger minimum wage increase than NAS (2019) and consider the impact in 2022 rather than in 2025 as does CBO (2019). Both those factors would lead us to find larger effects than the other studies as we would expect a large wage increase to have larger effects on both poverty and employment. Raising the minimum wage may have broader macroeconomic effects we do not consider in this analysis. If employers passed along their higher-wage costs to consumers in the form of higher prices, the ensuing price increases would offset some of the buying power gained by workers. But if employers addressed the rising minimum wage by taking lower profits or by slowing the wage growth of more highly compensated employees and lower-wage workers were more likely to spend their new earnings than owners and the highly compensated, then the higher minimum wage could spur demand and growth in the economy. Debates about the minimum wage at the federal and state levels have been ongoing for decades, and they likely will continue for decades into the future. Projections of the potential effects of raising the minimum wage that use sophisticated analytic tools like the ATTIS microsimulation model can illustrate how different estimates of the employment effects of the minimum wage influence outcomes and inform those debates. Here, we provide a range of results that flow from what we consider reasonable assumptions; they are not meant to be upper or lower bounds but illustrations of how raising the federal minimum wage may play out under those assumptions as well as a sense of the how alternative assumptions could affect the results. Our projections generally suggest notable income gains and poverty reductions from a $15 per hour minimum wage. And although millions of workers may experience a job loss they otherwise would not have as a result of the minimum wage, the time they do spend working during the year will be paid at a higher rate, and their family members may also enjoy higher earnings. As such, even those workers who would experience a job loss are, on average, modestly better off over the course of a year.