Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Minimum wage movements empower unionization – effective advocacy bolsters esteem for union leadership

Clemens 20 [Jeffrey & Michael R. Strain; October 2020; associate professor of economics at UC San Diego; director of Economic Policy Studies and the Arthur F. Burns Scholar in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute; National Bureau of Economic Research; “Public Policy and Participation in Political Interest Groups: An Analysis of Minimum Wages, Labor Unions, and Effective Advocacy”; 10.3386/w27902 KF]

Over the past decade, labor unions have emerged as advocates for historically high minimum wages. Since its inception in 2012, the “Fight for $15” movement has received substantial union support, ranging in intensity from simple expressions of solidarity to financial and organizational aid. 2 Over this same period, the public’s view of labor unions has become more favorable. Against this backdrop, we analyze the interplay among labor unions, minimum wages, news coverage, and public opinion. We assess what factors might drive participation in groups like labor unions, and how public policy and interest groups affect each other. We document that recent minimum wage increases have preceded increases in union membership. Over the past decade, a one-dollar increase in a state’s minimum wage predicts a 5 percent increase in union membership among those ages 16–40. As detailed below, we assess the case for interpreting this link as causal and find that case to be relatively strong. Increases in minimum wages predict a greater likelihood of union membership among groups of workers that do not benefit directly from minimum wage hikes. Why might this be? We find that minimums wage increases lead to news coverage that links minimum wages to key players in the labor movement. Higher minimum wages also predict higher public esteem for unions. Union membership may thus rise in the wake of minimum wage hikes because individuals value affiliating with groups that deliver “effective advocacy,” even if they do not 2 The AFL-CIO’s website, for example, includes “restoring the minimum wage to a living wage” in its statement of policy priorities for improving pay and benefits. (Accessed at the following link on May 5, 2020: https://aflcio.org/issues/better-pay-and-benefits). The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) has been relatively public regarding its operational and financial support for the Fight for $15. In a representative statement linking the fortunes of unions and the Fight for $15, SEIU President Mary Kay Henry wrote in 2019, “This movement will not stop until workers across the country win the $15 an hour and union rights they’ve demanded since Day One.” (Accessed at the following link on April 10, 2020: http://www.seiu.org/2019/01/seius-henry-fightfor-15-and-a-union-is-winning-for-americas-working-people-changing-whats-possible.) 3 benefit personally from the outcome of that advocacy. We also find that minimum wage increases reduce union membership among the workers who are most likely to benefit directly. This finding is consistent with a classic free-riding hypothesis, since unions and the minimum wage may be substitutable sources of bargaining power in the low-wage labor market. Our effort to isolate the causal effect of minimum wages on union membership faces three standard but nontrivial challenges. First, it could be that union strength was already rising in states that enacted minimum wage increases. That is, the correlation we observe may reflect reverse causality. Second, the correlation could arise from factors, like strengthening labor markets, that might simultaneously stimulate employment, union membership, and preferences for raising minimum wages. Third, states that are favorably disposed toward high minimum wages may, perhaps by chance or perhaps due to other policies, have been affected by other factors that increased rates of union membership.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.