Government stimulus weakens the incentive to work and increases reliance on federal spending, trapping people in poverty and stunting innovation.
Millsap ’23 [Adam; August 6; Senior Fellow for economic opportunity issues at Stand Together and Stand Together Trust; Forbes, "The High Costs Of Too Much Government Spending", https://www.forbes.com/sites/adammillsap/2021/08/06/the-high-costs-of-too-much-government-spending/?sh=40d4aa04ad67]
Too much spending reduces economic mobility via transfers and redistribution. In-kind and cash transfers reduce the incentive to work, and when coupled with sharp means-tested phase out rules—so-called benefits cliffs— and , such transfers often . Government aid, preferably cash transfers that empower people rather than micromanage them, is sometimes necessary to help people get back on their feet. Such aid should be timely, targeted, and temporary, and state and local governments, not the federal government, should play the lead role. The current social safety net is broken and , not more money to feed a system that prevents people from succeeding. Bottom-up ideas that leverage private philanthropy and cutting-edge market-tested solutions are the keys to sustainably reducing poverty and expanding opportunity. Too much spending hurts the environment by using resources inefficiently. Building stuff releases emissions and other pollutants that can damage the environment. As policy analyst Marc Joffe “During the construction process, new greenhouse gases are produced as steel and concrete are poured, and as vehicles operate at construction sites. Once...finished, those additional carbon emissions need to be factored in...” To mitigate waste and environmental damage, it’s vital to build stuff that people want and will use. The signals of profit and loss can help us determine the value of infrastructure projects, but these signals are often ignored when governments are involved. This results in more waste and unnecessary pollution. Notable examples include the , which has never met its ridership projections, and the in California that cost taxpayers nearly $200 million despite never being completed. California’s high-speed rail line is and behind schedule, but supporters are hoping that taxpayers will get the project back on track through federal subsidies in the current infrastructure bill. Each of these projects, and dozens of others, failed to meet the needs of potential users. This means that whatever environmental impacts they had were avoidable. We must be prudent about what we build and not just build for building’s sake. Finally, too much spending encourages a dependency on government that . Government spending financed by higher taxes reduces the incentive to start a new business or expand an existing one. Government redistribution often fosters a culture of dependency and discourages risk-taking. Eventually, an appreciation of innovation as the driver of economic progress is eroded and individuals take fewer moonshots. Countries such as France, Switzerland, Norway, and other Western European countries have high taxes and , which are privately owned startups with valuations of $1 billion or more. It’s clear that France and similar countries no longer have the desire, capability, or both, to harness the ingenuity and creativity of individuals in the private sector to achieve remarkable things. As Adam Thierer , “There are no European versions of Microsoft , Google , or Apple , even though Europeans obviously demand and consume the sort of products and services those U.S.-based companies provide. It’s simply not possible given the EU’s current regulatory regime.” Despite our policy challenges, America has the most innovative and dynamic economy in the world. We must protect it while simultaneously working to improve policy to encourage even more innovation. The dangers of too much government spending are being ignored. Countries and empires throughout history have used vast building projects to justify high levels of taxation and spending. But while adequate roads and bridges help the economy function, it is the people in the private sector who make it grow. It's imperative that government spends prudently so more resources remain in the hands of the entrepreneurs who are the true drivers of innovation.