Abolition democracy demands the creation of sustainable black communities – that is essential to avoid perpetuating the sins of slavery through racial capitalism.
Inwood et al, ’20 - Department of Geography and Rock Ethics Institute, Pennsylvania State University [Joshua F.J. Anna Brand, Elise Quinn, December 19, 2020, Antipode, “Racial Capital, Abolition, and a Geographic Argument for Reparations”, https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/anti.12704, June 24, 2023, LN]
Lipsitz (2004:273) notes that abolition democracy was “forged from the free- dom dreams and collective struggles of an enslaved peoples” that ended slavery and, in the intervening years after the war, created the conditions for an expan- sive democratic vision of America. He explains that newly freed enslaved peoples wanted more than nominal freedom; they wanted to develop a government sys- tem that allowed for the full development of their human potential. The work of abolition democracy to remake the South in the aftermath of the Civil War is central to Geography and Geography’s role in furthering the call for reparations (Gilbert and Williams 2020). Arguably, it is the focus on land and property that constitutes the most radical and liberatory efforts of abolition democracy to remake a property relation forged through slavery (Harris 1993; Heynen 2018). Directly addressing the role of whiteness in creating and maintain- ing property regimes is important because as Harris (1993) argues, the role of slavery in creating our modern property regime is a heavy weight that has long stymied and undermined the quest for justice. Property regimes forged through slavery sideline broader calls for inclusion that are central to creating more inclu- sive and well-functioning societies (Harris 1993:1791). Abolition practice was an attempt to rewrite the foundational aspects of America in humanely sustainable ways. McLeod (2018:1619), borrowing from Angela Davis, argues that abolition democracy, at its core, is about a “conception of justice that not only attends carefully to the actual outcomes of processes ...but seeks to distribute resources and opportunities more equitably”. It is the second focus, which is central to reparations and the work of reparative justice. What if, for example, in the aftermath of the Lehman Brothers collapse, that instead of having its bankrupted mortgage portfolio divided up and sold to other banks if that land and property had been returned to the community through reparation land banks, controlled by residents and community partners? The idea of property as a community resource could be used in ways that are locally ori- ented and controlled through cooperative democratic collectives. How might the financial collapse and mortgage crisis of 2007 have played out differently if those properties, instead of being foreclosed upon, could have been used to support and develop communities in ways that made sense to and with the residents who lived within those geographic areas? Robin Kelley (2002:125) argues that, in the context of reparations, land redistribution is crucially important to redistributing wealth, and in the building up of community resources. Property has long been a pillar of white wealth, the growth of intergenerational wealth, and in militarisation as the nation oriented itself around indigenous removal and land confiscation. It is the very foundation of repressive laws and a justice system that rarely takes col- lective rights claims into account, especially as it relates to racial justice. Property is the heart of the American empire. Rethinking how and in what ways we use property, its value and how that value can be oriented around local communities to empower and grow Black institutions, is one of several ways reparation policies and practices could and should be used to sustain communities of colour. Instead of processes of abandonment, we might be able to craft new ways of investment in the very spaces and places that are most in need and in ways that focus on local, community control. Far from seeing these spaces as dysfunctional or devoid of life, we should see them as incubators for radical liberation and the kind of expansive and humane democracy that so many have struggled to create. As a liberation project, abolition democracy’s efforts are more than mere his- tory; abolition opens up space to think through radical and multi-racial projects that, when coupled with the broader movement towards reparations, can recon- figure the American racial landscape. Writing in Development Arrested, Clyde Woods (1998:141) notes that the key to the restoration of white supremacist rule first and foremost was the creation of a “system of legal and private terror”. He writes that violence, both legal and extra-judicial, was dispensed with impunity to subdue and regulate African Americans in the South. The system that he describes is precisely the system that the Lehman Brothers profited from, supported, and used to accrue their ill-gotten gains. It is also the system which continues pro- cesses of uneven development that is so critical to the expansion and mainte- nance of the variegated landscapes of difference central to the workings of racial capitalism (Melamed 2011, 2015; Pulido 2017) and racial violence. At the heart of reparative justice and the work of reparations must be the transformation of both the legal and extra-legal violences that exist and work to maintain differ- ence. These transformations toward liberation must be, as Gilmore (2017) argues, a place. Abolition democracy is an effort that not only exposes “the violence, hypocrisy and disassembling entrenched in existing legal practices” but also moves to “achieve peace, make amends and distribute resources” in an effort wholly focused on transforming the condition in which we live (McLeod 2018:1615). At the heart of this is a realisation that resistance to the present systems of exploita- tion can only be addressed by: Addressing how mainstream economic practices and arrangements perpetrate violent theft every day in ways that can be thoroughly redressed only by democratising politi- cal and economic institutions to prevent and respond to the highly unequal distribu- tion of resources and life chances. (McLeod 2018:1616)