Opposition to a UBI is entrenched in racist language and ideology
Chambers et al, 2022 – prof of political science at Trinity College [Stefani, with Abby Nick and Maddie Granato, May 3 “The Benefits of Guaranteed Basic Income: Lessons from Advocates” https://www.trincoll.edu/cher/blog/abby-nick-cwealf/ Acc 3/23/23 TA]
A. Advocates warned against opponents’ use of coded racist language A key theme throughout my interviews and research was that much of the opposition to basic income programs is rooted in racial and economic discrimination. Opponents disguise racist intents into common language in debates and discussions. Advocates explained that many opponents see GBI as a free giveaway, offering free income to those too lazy to work. David Grant, head of the Hartford GBI task force, explained the opposition Hartford faced from surrounding majority-white towns: “Our surrounding sister cities and towns have residents that are absolutely against [GBI]. They see it as a free giveaway… And so there are these divides, these cultural divides that exist even in a state like Connecticut… I learned very quickly doing this work just how divided the community is on a program like GBI” The biggest opposition to the basic income program is the shame wrongly associated with giving money. We as a society view these programs as handouts and instead as assistance in rectifying a broken and inequitable system. Madeline Neighly, the Director of Guaranteed Income at the Economic Security Project stated: “I think honestly, the biggest opposition is one of narrative. It is a deeply held, deeply ingrained belief around pulling yourself up by your bootstraps. There are both spoken and undercurrents of gendered racism around who is deserving.” (Neighly) Advocates then explained that this opposition is often racially charged and when advocating for GBI you must be wary of opponents using racist language, Neighly went on to say: “And I think there are very key prime examples that people are much more aware of, like the welfare queen racist trope, but it’s much deeper than that. So there are dog whistles that are used, There are ways in which we’ve all been steeped in that culture, and it’s really hard to challenge that both externally and within ourselves… One should be able to live in dignity because of their existence, not because of their value in the labor market.” When advocating for GBI and UBI programs we must be aware of this underlying bias within conversation and opposition strategies.