Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Raising the Minimum wage fails:

No behavioral response among firms and workers (will lead to unemployment)

No innovation to offset higher costs (companies will shrink)

Makridis 16 [Christos Makridis; February 5 2016; a Ph.D. Candidate in Macroeconomics and Public Finance at Stanford University; The New Republic; “Raising the Minimum Wage Won’t Reduce Inequality”; ; CP]

Walmart is giving more than one million of its employees a raise later this month as part of a plan that will lift all but its newest hires to at least $10 an hour. The move, first announced last year, follows an aggressive campaign to get the largest private employer in the U.S. to lift worker wages and coincides with a nationwide push to raise federal and state minimum wages and a prolonged period of little growth in pay. While Walmart’s decision is at least in part a result of that pressure, it’s still the action of a private company to revamp its own wage policies, as opposed to the result of a government forcing it to lift worker pay. Proponents of requiring just that argue raising the minimum helps reduce inequality. Critics contend it can actually worsen it by driving up unemployment and weakening economy-wide labor market flexibility by raising the costs firms face. So what does the economic research say about the impact of minimum wages on income inequality and is there a better way to reduce it? Minimum wage fallacies. Many of the articles in the mainstream press promoting minimum wages are incompatible with basic economic principles. The first fallacy is that changes in the minimum wage do not affect the behavioral response among firms and individuals. The second fallacy is that higher wages will force companies to innovate in order to reduce costs. Both these arguments overlook some very basic, but informative, economic principles. The first overlooks the fact that wages are designed to compensate workers for productivity. When wages are distorted, they affect the profit-maximizing decisions that businesses make. The textbook prediction, which is generally supported in the data, is that higher minimum wages reduce employment since companies restrict the number of workers they will hire. These adverse effects are especially likely given the pace of technological change and automation. The second overlooks the fact that there are effective and ineffective ways to stimulate innovation among businesses. The idea that making hiring more costly will spur innovation is tantamount to requiring companies to reduce the size of their physical presence so they become more productive. While these types of distortions may prompt a small fraction of companies to innovate, misallocation more generally is a major factor behind cross-country differences in productivity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.