Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

CP causes offshoring – this directly causes people to vote against the incumbent

Rickard ’21 [Stephanie J, 3-5-21; Department of Government, London School of Economics and Politics,; British Journal of Political Science, “Incumbents Beware: The Impact of Offshoring on Elections, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/british-journal-of-political-science/article/incumbents-beware-the-impact-of-offshoring-on-elections/ IG]

First, voters may view offshoring as a preventable loss, whereas job losses from other sources, such as a mismanaged company, are not. Because governments can (and do) provide firms with generous economic incentives to keep jobs onshore, voters may consequently view offshoring as a result of government inaction and vote against the incumbent government party in the subsequent election. Secondly, the costs of job losses from offshoring may be higher than the costs of job losses from other sources. Offshored workers typically have a different age and/or skill profile than other unemployed persons. In Spain, for example, workers who were unemployed because of Table 3. The possibility of retraining to obtain jobs under similar conditions was limited. To obtain new jobs after theirs moved abroad, many workers had to accept worse pay or temporary jobs (Miguélez Lobo 2004). If offshored workers face relatively higher costs from becoming unemployed, then government compensation may fail to appease them at the same rate it does for other citizens who lost their jobs for different reasons. Thirdly, different types of job losses may have varied labor market effects. If production moves to a new location within a country, rather than abroad, suppliers may continue to exist. As a result, fewer jobs will be lost when a plant relocates production to a different part of the country, as compared to a foreign country. Furthermore, jobs that move abroad are not coming back, while those that move to a different part of the country are ‘recoverable’. People can follow the production by moving to a different part of the country and seeking re-employment. This may help explain why twice as many respondents identified offshoring as an event that would make them less likely to vote for the incumbent than the closure of a local business to move to a different part of Spain. Finally, the media’s coverage of offshoring may elicit a disproportionate voter reaction. When covering offshoring, the media often explicitly identifies foreign competition as the cause of the job losses and sometimes even names a specific foreign country (Margalit 2011, 184). In 90 per cent of the cases in my sample, I could identify the country to which production was moving from media reports alone.30 The fact that offshoring is closely associated with ‘others’ may trigger voters’ nationalism and/or ethnocentrism (for example, Mansfield and Mutz 2013; Margalit 2011). While a perception that foreigners are taking away ‘our jobs’ may stir nationalist or ethnocentric sentiments, it is not obvious why this would necessarily lead to an anti-incumbent vote. Further research is needed to explore this and other potential mechanisms that may uniquely link offshoring to anti-incumbent voting.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.