Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No evidence guaranteed income solves crime – it is a highly inefficient and expensive method to even try

Robert E. Wright (Senior Faculty Fellow at the American Institute for Economic Research) “Universal basic income isn’t a sensible crime-fighting tool” April 23, 2023 https://www.ocregister.com/2023/04/23/universal-basic-income-isnt-a-sensible-crime-fighting-tool/

Ahsha Safai, a member of San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors, recently opined in USA Today that a universal or unconditional basic income (UBI) would help San Francisco to alleviate its crime problem. The claim might signal the author’s virtue but it has no basis in reality and falls far short of passing a policy-grade cost-benefit analysis. No real UBI has yet been implemented anywhere so its effect on crime remains unknown. A real UBI would be an expensive policy with unknown effects on myriad important outcomes in education, health, and human freedom. So, even if it were to reduce crime, the overall cost of the reduction might prove prohibitively high in absolute terms. It would almost certainly be too high relative to alternative crime reduction policies, especially those with historical precedent. Numerous newspaper headlines suggest that UBI “pilots” and “experiments” have become ubiquitous and that they prove the efficacy of UBI programs. Such headlines mislead because none of the programs are universal (paid to everyone), unconditional (paid to all regardless of class, gender, race, religion, etc.), basic (neither too little nor too large), and income (a permanent stream of cash). Moreover, most US UBI pilot programs received funding from nonprofits, not from the taxes upon which they would ultimately have to rely. Their effects on work incentives therefore remain unknown. In other words, UBI pilot programs to date prove nothing other than the undisputed fact that most people will feel, and actually be, better off if they receive “free money” donated by a distant charity like manna from heaven. If Safai’s real goal is to reduce crime, that can be achieved at much lower cost than UBI. The gross cost of a UBI of $15,000 in San Fran (assuming the population remains around 815,000) would be about $12.25 billion per year. Given that non-San Francisco people will not willingly fund a San Francisco UBI, that money would have to come out of other city expenditures, which would be quite a feat given that its current budget is about $14 billion. Or it could come from higher taxes. Much of the UBI itself could be taxed back, leaving a net cost of, say, $2 billion/year. But how much crime reduction would $2 billion of income redistribution buy? And what else could $2 billion a year buy the city? More police officers, improved 911 services, additional job training programs, and such, as Safai suggests. More of the same old, critics of the status quo will complain.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.