AND, the impact’s not universal---nuclear use reproduces spatial injustices through targeting procedures.
Jacqueline Foertsch 13. Professor of English at the University of North Texas. 08/30/2013. Reckoning Day: Race, Place, and the Atom Bomb in Postwar America. Vanderbilt University Press.
More broadly speaking, one’s location in the American landscape when the bomb exploded—that is, during America’s early atomic/cold war era—intersects with one’s “place” in the American social hierarchy in significant ways. For the bomb presented Americans, especially those who have always enjoyed more freedom of movement, with a series of spatio-ethical dilemmas: where to go if the bombs should fall, who and what to leave behind. While the suburban boom of the immediate postwar period had myriad causes, one significant reason was the strong sense that America’s cities were the easiest and most likely of nuclear targets. Elaine Tyler May has examined the leafy, low-slung, spread-out qualities of American suburbs and has persuasively observed in these a response to atomic fears of urban verticality, congestion, and entrapment. For May it was especially the hunkered down, ranch-style home that “exuded this sense of isolation, privacy, and containment” (94). In atomic fictions of the period, the city is depicted as the site of conflagration; those characters lucky enough to find themselves in the suburbs or on the farm on “X-day” fare better and depend less on which way the wind blows during the fallout period. While the suburban choice—again, for the white middle-class, for whom such choices were exclusively provided—seemed obvious, the decision with respect to whether or not to go underground, to build a bomb shelter and prepare to survive there in the atomic aftermath, was always a more fraught proposition. In the enmeshed social setting of the suburbs, how would it look to build a shelter when no one else was doing so? Kenneth D. Rose suggests that the lone suburban shelter-digger might seem not only eccentric (violating the cardinal rule of conformity) but also “immoral.” “At issue,” says Rose, “was controlling entry to one’s personal or community shelter . . . to keep out radioactive fallout but also ‘to prevent exceeding the maximum capacity of the shelter’” (93). How did one build to suit one’s immediate family but not spaciously enough to include neighbors and passersby, or even parents, in-laws, aunts, and uncles from the “old country” (i.e., the urban birthplace)? The pointlessness of resurfacing in a ruined, depopulated post-nuclear environment may have dissuaded many from taking the plunge in the first place; others sought the furthest reaches of American civilization (and beyond) in their understanding that the key to nuclear survival was location, location, location. We attach extremist notions like nuclear survivalism to a specific racial, classed position in the US—white (sometimes white-supremacist) lower-class place-holders who take to the hinterlands in order to reject not only the nuclear jeopardy in which America has placed its citizens from the cold war to the present but also much of what America represents (see, e.g., “Religious Group”). Such outward-boundedness positions one near the bottom of America’s social scale, while downward-boundedness (bomb shelter-building) was a distinctly suburban (and, to some degree, urban) phenomenon and thus associated with America’s middle class. In short, there was less stigma attached during the cold war to digging down than to lighting out, despite the seemingly more bizarre nature of the downward-digging: while survivalists thrive on the US’s geographic and ideological margins into the twenty-first century, today no middle-class suburbanite would construct a bomb shelter in his backyard, so unorthodox an act would it be, and the two-hour commute has become more and more the norm. Perhaps, sixty years ago, a move to the suburbs was deemed so eminently respectable that included with the purchase of one’s private lot was the right to go a little crazy in one’s fenced-off backyard—to prepare for a post-nuclear life underground no matter how objectionable it was to some. In America’s “burnt out,” “bombed out” urban cores, locales we have tagged with post-nuclear adjectives since the postwar period,1 remained America’s “undesirables”—African, Asian, and Latino Americans and other ethnic persons or immigrants with low incomes; poor whites; the elderly; gays and lesbians; the mentally disturbed; the otherwise socially delinquent. Ironically, their lives in inner city high-rises positioned these postwar Americans “at the top,” while everyone understood that such physical superiority carried neither privilege nor security. If anything, the last place one wanted to be at this moment was up, and yet this particular sector of the American population had few other choices: the suburbs were closed to them, rural ties had been severed generations earlier, and the atomic threat found many of America’s persons of color trapped at ground zero. Questioning “the Negro’s relative exposure and immunity to nuclear annihilation” for Negro Digest in 1963, the sociologist and black studies founder Nathan Hare praised African Americans’ emotional fortitude and resistance to physical travails—even the anticipated intense heat of atomic blast—due to their “cotton-chopping, cotton-picking backgrounds in the Southern sun and long years of tending ovens and furnaces in white kitchens and factories” (31). Yet Hare is intent on critiquing the demographic patterns of postwar society that have trapped the black community in northern ghettoes “near the centers or bull’s-eyes of our big cities” (28). Citing racial residency patterns at that point, Hare notes that “a 10-megaton bomb on Washington, DC, or Chicago . . . would just about take care of the Negro community” (29). Hare’s observations are echoed today by Katherine McKittrick and Clyde Woods, who decry America’s long history of “uneven geographies,” wherein “black and poor subjects are disposable precisely because they cannot move or escape” (3). This insight crystallizes the crisis faced by atomic-era African Americans, thought to deserve their fate for failing to meet the criteria for admission to the suburban safe haven. Philip Wylie’s novel Tomorrow! is a nuclear preparedness/survival fantasy that includes a map of the fictional sister cities that are its setting; these surround a “Negro District” that is dead-center during the climactic nuclear explosion. The story ends with its surviving characters, all of whom are white, viewing a scene of pristine, suburban-style rebirth. This vision resonates with those of postwar urban planners who could not but associate the bomb, despite its frightening implications, with their growing desire to revamp city life, specifically to “save the American city from ‘the blight . . . gnawing at its innards’” (qtd. in P. Boyer 152). The National Paint, Varnish, and Lacquer Association produced a fright-mongering public service announcement in the mid-1950s that has achieved cult status in the intervening decades, The House in the Middle. As it opens, a disgusted narrator harangues against the combustible trash and rotting wood “you’ve seen in too many alleys and backyards—in slum areas” and crows about the destruction suffered by cluttered, littered, unpainted frame houses subjected to H-bombing at the Nevada Proving Grounds, images of which accompany his voiceover. Only the paint job of the lucky middle house saves it from the same fate, itself racialized, since “light colors” and “white” are recommended as the most light- and heat-reflective shades. Implicit in such texts, therefore, are visions of the nuclear-induced “urban renewal” that recent thinkers such as Martha A. Bartter and Dean MacCannell have broadly denounced, while Michele Birnbaum incisively reads the constructedness of racial identity thus: “we can describe one [race] only in terms of the other—a kind of Heisenberg principle of race in which racial difference is situational, provisional: it depends upon who is looking and who is next to whom” (3). As whiteness depends for its significance upon its position with respect to blackness (and vice versa), we see this supplemental relation repeated in the demographic shifting of the postwar US: African Americans, forced to remain in rapidly declining inner cities, maintained these locales as viable (i.e., populated) nuclear targets, creating in turn the relative safety of the “uninhabited” white suburban sanctuary.