States solve - they are primary vehicles of fiscal redistribution and can have a massive impact on the significance of economic inequality
ELIZABETH MCNICHOL DECEMBER 15, 2016 | How State Tax Policies Can Stop Increasing Inequality and Start Reducing It https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/how-state-tax-policies-can-stop-increasing-inequality-and-start
Over the last three and one-half decades, income gains in the American economy have accrued largely to the richest households, while many middle- and lower-income Americans haven’t shared in the nation’s growing prosperity. This has reduced opportunities for working people striving to get ahead and weakened our overall economy. Though the growth in inequality reflects a host of long-standing national and global economic trends that are largely outside state policymakers’ control (see box below), state policy choices can make matters worse or improve them.
For example, virtually all states collect more taxes from moderate- and lower-income families, as a share of their income, than high-income families (see Figure 1). This increases inequality by reducing after-tax incomes more deeply among low- and middle-income families than high-income families.
The mechanisms by which state tax systems ask less of the wealthy than of poor and middle-income families have developed over time, often through closed-door negotiations resulting in special tax breaks that benefit a relative few. To reverse these trends, states should avoid actions — such as cutting income taxes or raising sales taxes — that worsen inequality by shifting taxes further to lower-income residents. Instead, they should ensure that high-income earners pay their share and lower-income earners don’t face increased tax responsibility. For example, states could:
Make their income taxes more effective at reducing inequality through steps such as levying higher rates on high-income taxpayers or capping itemized deductions.
Establish or expand taxes on inherited wealth, such as estate taxes.
Strengthen taxes on corporations, such as by eliminating costly tax breaks — which enable many profitable corporations to pay zero state income taxes in some states where they do business — and establishing strong minimum taxes or adopting “combined reporting” (a reform that nullifies three of the most common state corporate tax shelters).
Broaden the sales tax base to include more services purchased by wealthy individuals.
Boost incomes among low- and moderate-wage working families by enacting state earned income tax credits.
Maintain an overall tax system that raises sufficient revenue to pay for the building blocks of shared prosperity, such as education and access to health care.
Across the country, the wealthiest residents have been the overwhelming beneficiaries of the uneven growth in incomes. The average income of the top 5 percent of households is now at least ten times that of the bottom 20 percent in every state, according to 2015 American Community Survey data. In the typical state, the average income of the top 5 percent was $325,928 compared to just $22,014 for the bottom 20 percent and $66,165 for the middle 20 percent. Moreover, these figures understate income disparities because they omit capital gains income, which is heavily concentrated among the richest households.[1] (Tables 1-4 provide comparative income data by state.)
The fact that the lion’s share of income gains has gone to the wealthiest residents contradicts the basic American belief that hard work should pay off — that the people who contribute to the nation’s economic growth should reap their share of the benefits of that growth. It also harms the health of those falling behind and diminishes educational opportunities for children growing up in less affluent areas. In short, such inequality is both a barrier to Americans striving to provide for themselves and their families and a drag on future economic growth. Reducing it should be a high priority for state policymakers.