No follow on – feds won’t act states only model federal government not the other way around.
Herrera 13 (Dr. Richard, Professor of Political Science at Arizona State University, PhD from University of California, Santa Barbara, and Dr. Karen Shafer, Professor at Walden University, PhD in Political Science from Arizona State University, “Governors’ Policy Agendas Over the Long Haul: State Priorities in a National Context”, Paper Presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, 9/1/2013, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2300597&download=yes)
Evidence that the states are influenced by the federal government’s policy agenda is mixed. In the area of social welfare policy recent research shows little influence (Heidbreder 2008). Welch and Thompson (1980), however, do find some evidence that states respond to positive federal incentives in a variety of policy areas. Specifically, states are stimulated to act faster when provided incentives than when policies are not so accompanied. Similarly Daley and Garand, using environmental policies related to hazardous waste, found some modest support for the hypothesis that “States that receive higher funding for environmental programs are somewhat more likely…to adopt stringent hazardous waste regulations that mimic federal Superfund program” (2005, 634-35). They conclude “signals from the federal government” will prompt states to act in this policy area (Daley and Garand 2005, 631). Barrilleaux, et al. (2002), also find that states react to federal activities in the area of welfare spending. These studies show federal influence on state policies driven by federal incentives specifically designed to trigger state action. In their study of anti-smoking policies, Shipan and Volden (2006) examine three types of diffusion, local-state, state-state, and national-state and find evidence of national-state pressures resulting in policy adoptions that do not always rely on federal incentives. Evidence the federal government is taking cues from the states is also mixed. Boekelman (1992) examined a variety of federal laws for state influences and found limited effects mostly in the areas of redistributive policies such as child care, homeless aid, and welfare reform. Using 5 interviews with federal policy makers, Mossberger (1999) found some inadvertent state-federal diffusion in the area of enterprise zones. Respondents in her study were aware of trends in state policy making and Mossberger concludes that any influence from the states is limited (1999, 49). In their study of vertical diffusion in the area of health policy, Weissert and Scheller (2008) find some indication of influence, but conclude that the story is complicated due to a lack of policy learning. As they state, “Federal health officials are considering and often adopting policies in health areas in which state actions have occurred. But the federal actions show little recognition of state experiences” (Weissert and Scheller 2008, S171). Thompson and Burke (2007) examined health policy as well and found modest evidence of state policies leading federal ones. The recent work by Lowery, et al. (2011), using a variety of policy areas from state level bill introductions finds no evidence of bottom up effects. Our study differs from others on policy diffusion in the following respects. Most other studies tend to focus on a single issue such as health care (Weissert and Scheller 2008) or environmental policy (Daley and Garand 2005) or make no distinctions among varying policy types (Lowery et al. 2011). Most studies are not longitudinal. And, most studies concentrate on a single step in the policymaking process. We consider three policy areas – education, economics and health - separately, over a period of 20 years and examine varying stages of the federal policymaking including congressional hearings, State of the Union addresses, the passages of public laws.