The fed doesn’t model states.
Chatterji ‘15 (Aaron; 1/11/15; Ph.D. in Business Administration from the University of California at Berkeley, B.A. in Economics from Cornell University, Associate Professor of Strategy in the Fuqua School of Business at Duke University, Associate Professor of Public Policy at the Sanford School of Public Policy, Visiting Associate Professor at the Harvard Business School, former senior economist with the White House Council of Economic Advisers; New York Times, “Don’t Look to States for New Ideas,” https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/12/opinion/dont-look-to-states-for-new-ideas.html)
The problem is, just when we need their innovative energies, the states are looking less and less likely to be fountainheads of new federal policy over the next generation. What has changed? First, state politics have become much more partisan. After the 2014 elections, 60 percent of the states are completely controlled by a single party. The power of state policy innovations is that they traditionally had bipartisan fingerprints, allowing an enterprising national politician from either party to lay claim to them. In the new world of single-party states, very little bipartisan legislation will emerge. We will see no Democrat willing to adopt the radical tax reforms of Gov. Sam Brownback, Republican of Kansas, and surely no Republican could champion the Safe Act that Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo, a Democrat, got passed in New York — one of the strictest gun control bills in the nation. Of course, these ideas may diffuse to other like-minded states. But more likely, these new initiatives will be at one end of the political spectrum or the other, limiting the potential for federal adoption. Second, it has become clear that “scaling” successful state policies is harder than it appears, because of both political forces and policy realities. Every technocrat in Washington dreams of finding a successful policy at the state level, an early childhood education program in North Carolina or a creative prison reform initiative in Texas, and using it as a model for federal legislation. The logic is that once a state “laboratory” has tested and approved a particular policy innovation, it will have the same “treatment” effect in the other 49 states. But that hasn’t been the case. Increasingly, efforts to “federalize” state innovations have been hobbled [impeded] by political backlash. The Obama administration’s Race to the Top program used billions of dollars of prize money to persuade states to adopt several education policy reforms that had been proven to work around the nation. Part of the package was Common Core, which, in part because of President Obama’s imprimatur, is now toxic on the right (and, because of opposition from some teachers, is just as toxic on the left). Of course, despite their zeal for federalism, many conservatives never really agreed with Justice Brandeis’s nostrum to begin with. They worry that successful state policies might not translate well to the federal level, even under ideal conditions — witness the skepticism with which Congressional Republicans greeted President Obama’s announcement last week of a new initiative to help students attend community college, based on a program in Tennessee. And they have a point: It turns out scaling a successful state program often ends up with a one-size-fits-all policy that might work well in Ohio but fall flat in Arizona. An economic development program centered on promoting entrepreneurship might work in Silicon Valley, Boston or Austin, Tex., but fail miserably in an area without leading universities and a highly educated work force. Moreover, federal mandates, in which Washington sets up rules and the states run with them, hopefully innovating along the way, have not fared much better. The Medicaid expansion was intended to be a core pillar of the Affordable Care Act, but following a 5-to-4 Supreme Court decision, many states chose to opt out. Finally, all politics aside, while tax revenues have been increasing recently, many states remain cash-strapped since the Great Recession, limiting their ability to initiate significant economic or social programs of any kind. Taken together, these forces mean that while states might experiment with numerous policies over the coming years, very few will ever go national. For those of us frustrated with federal gridlock, the states will provide little comfort going forward. The 50 laboratories of democracy will produce many so-called cures, but none of them will go down very well in our nation’s capital.