Bipartisan opposition to a universal basic income
Program for Public Consultation, School of Public Policy, University of Maryland August 7, 2020 Major Report Shows Nearly 150 Issues on Which Majorities of Republicans & Democrats Agree https://publicconsultation.org/defense-budget/major-report-shows-nearly-150-issues-on-which-majorities-of-republicans-democrats-agree/
Defying conventional wisdom about a polarized electorate, a report based on in-depth surveys of more than 80,000 Americans shows that majorities from both parties agree on nearly 150 key policy positions across more than a dozen top policy areas. The research suggests that Americans are eager for their elected representatives to cross party lines to start tackling the nation’s toughest problems. The , released at an event organized by two nonpartisan organizations, and , is based primarily on more than 30 in-depth surveys conducted by the at the University of Maryland. In the surveys, respondents were given in-depth information about the policy issues and legislative proposals under consideration in Congress, and evaluated arguments for and against each policy option before coming to their conclusions. The content was reviewed by experts at both ends of the spectrum of opinion on the issues. “What’s striking is that when citizens think through the issues and hear both sides, they often find common ground–clearly, much more so than Members of Congress,” said Steven Kull, president of Voice of the People and director of the Program for Public Consultation. The positions on which majorities from both parties agree span a broad swath of America’s most important and contentious issue areas, including police reform, immigration, poverty and jobs, social security, budget and taxes, health care, trade, energy and the environment, nuclear weapons and government reform. “On issue after issue, Americans agree across party lines and are ready to get things done – all these positions are also supported by majorities from both parties in the reddest and bluest Congressional districts, and by primary voters who are typically more partisan,” said Jillian Youngblood, Executive Director of Common Ground Solutions. At the nationwide release event, CNN’s Senior Congressional Correspondent Manu Raju discussed the findings with Amy Dacey, Executive Director of American University’s , and Kristie De Peña, Vice President for Policy and Director of Immigration at the . Financial support for the multi-year study was provided by the Democracy Fund, the Hewlett Foundation, the Rockefeller Brothers Fund, the MacArthur Foundation and the Circle Foundation. A SELECTION OF COMMON GROUND POSITIONS Social Security To address the projected Social Security shortfall and head off reductions in benefits, very large bipartisan majorities favor making reductions in benefits (reducing benefits to the top 25% of earners, gradually raising the retirement age to 68) and increasing taxes (raising the payroll tax from 6.2% to at least 6.6%, and raising the cap on income subject to the payroll tax to $215,000 or more). These steps would eliminate two thirds of the shortfall. A more modest bipartisan majority would eliminate the cap on income subject to the payroll tax, which, together with the other steps, eliminates the shortfall entirely. Immigration A large bipartisan majority favors giving immigrants who were illegally brought to the US as children legal status and a path to citizenship. A bipartisan majority would go further and provide a visa and path to citizenship to all undocumented workers who have been in the US for an extended period. Very large bipartisan majorities favor increasing the number of work visas. Bipartisan majorities favor more immigration judges to deal with asylum applications. To deter further illegal immigration, there is not majority support for a stronger barrier on the southern border – but a large bipartisan majority favors requiring employers to use the E-Verify system to establish the legal status of all their employees and all new applicants. Poverty Programs Large bipartisan majorities favor increasing SNAP benefits (aka food stamps), but do not want them to be used for sweetened sodas or candy. Bipartisan majorities also favor: making pre-kindergarten available to all 4-year-olds in low-income families raising the minimum wage to $9 an hour expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit major federal jobs programs in the event of an economic downturn. There is bipartisan opposition to a universal basic income of $1,000 a month, and to providing every child with a bond.