Huge political obstacles to Medicare for All. The division is powerful and sustained.
Michael S. Sparer, JD, PhD 2019 States as Policy Laboratories: The Politics of State-Based Single-Payer Proposals Am J Public Health. 2019 November; 109(11): 1511–1514. Published online 2019 November. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2019.305294 PMCID: PMC6775896 PMID: 31536399 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6775896/
Despite the gains generated by the Affordable Care Act (ACA), more than 30 million Americans remain uninsured, and millions more delay or defer needed medical care because of high deductibles and other out-of-pocket costs. This ongoing policy challenge prompts an increasing cadre of progressive Democrats to call for a comprehensive overhaul of the nation’s health care system, dramatically reducing (or perhaps completely eliminating) the multipayer private insurance health insurance industry and replacing it with comprehensive publicly funded coverage for all, referred to generally as a “single-payer” insurance model.1 Although the focus for most single-payer advocates is Washington, DC, where the rhetorical movement for Medicare for all animates the presidential campaigns of numerous Democratic candidates, there are also efforts in a handful of states to enact a state-based single-payer program that could become a model for federal policymakers.2 The political obstacles to the single-payer movement are obvious.3 First, the interest group opposition is fierce, wealthy, and influential. Opponents include private insurers worried about being forced into bankruptcy, providers worried about lower reimbursement, employers worried about higher taxes and lost control over employee benefits, unions worried about losing dollars generated by their health benefit programs, and of course a variety of conservative and Republican advocacy groups. Interest group support for single payer is far weaker, more fragmented, and less wealthy. Single-payer proposals also raise concerns about the appropriate role of government and the division of labor between the public and private sectors. These concerns are especially powerful here in the United States, where an antigovernment ethos resonates strongly with much of the population and where the view that government is less competent than the private sector is deeply engrained. This context makes any effort to dramatically raise taxes to fund a single-payer system even more difficult, even when economists point to administrative efficiencies, long-term system savings, and the elimination of insurance premiums. The odds of overcoming these obstacles are better at the state level than in Washington, DC.