Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Econ decline causes persecution and repression of minorities

Kanat 12 - the Research Director at the SETA Foundation at Washington DC. He is also an Assistant Professor of Political Science at Penn State University, Erie. Dr. Kanat received his PhD in Political Science from Syracuse University; a Master’s degree in Political Science from Syracuse University; and a Master’s in International Affairs from Marquette University. He was awarded the Outstanding Research Award and Council of Fellows Faculty Research Award at Penn State, Erie in 2015. He previously participated in the Future Leaders program of Foreign Policy Initiative.

(Kilic, ““War on Terror” as a Diversionary Strategy: Personifying Minorities as Terrorists in the People’s Republic of China”, p508-509, Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, Routledge)

According to Tir and Jasinski, for the beleaguered leaders, to use force against ethnic minorities and scapegoat them for the domestic problems of the country may be a more favorable option. This strategy is considered both cost effective and less risky for leaders compared to using force against an external other to deflect public attention. Especially, considering the high level of uncertainty in international conflicts and the possible international opposition in the case of an attack on another state, ethnic minority groups provide more secure and less internationalized targets. Again, for these leaders, compared to classical forms of diversionary strategies and the externalization of domestic conflicts, targeting and scapegoating ethnic minorities are more containable, since the targeted group and the conflict or attack would take place within domestic boundaries, and since there is usually a high degree of reluctance among international organizations and other states to become involved in the domestic conflicts of another state, mostly because of the possible ramifications of their policies on their own domestic problems.10 Tir and Jasinski note that although diverting the domestic public’s attention and gaining public support by attacking ethnic minorities can in some cases be extremely costly and risky, due to the possible spread and prolongation of this conflict, it is still a more viable option for many political leaders. Tir and Jasinski call this strategy “domestic-level diversion” and argue that it is not only available to a larger number of leaders, which challenges the US-centric assumption of classical diversionary scholarship, but that it also often presents a less risky course of action than external diversion, 508 Kilic Bugra Kanat which can be considered another attempt to rescue diversionary theory from the use of force and war.11 Tir and Jasinski found that in the period under study, which includes dates between 1996 and 2002, 15 countries used force against minorities at risk (MAR) in each year. This group of countries contains both democratic and authoritarian countries, including Uganda, Israel, Thailand, India, and China; whereas 43 other countries attacked their minorities through most of those years. According to their study, “both economic underperformance and government unpopularity are associated with statistically significant increases in the likelihood of governmental use of force against MAR groups”. 12 In another model in the same study, Tir and Jasinski change the dependent variable to indicate repressive activities against the minorities that fall short of the use of armed force, including arrest and detention of group members, show trials, execution of leaders, resettlement, etc. The result of this model also confirms “that lower intensity repression against MARs is indeed connected with economic underperformance and government unpopularity”. 13

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.