Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Political capital is finite and decisive.

Cohen ’19 [Jeffrey E; June; Political Science Professor at Fordham University; the President on Capitol Hill: A Theory of Institutional Influence, “Conclusions: Presidential Influence in Congress,” Ch. 11, p. 241-243]

The present study rehabilitates the idea of presidential influence in Congress. Instead of viewing influence as derived from personal characteristics, this study conceptualizes presidential influence in institutional terms. The major finding here is that presidents have a measurable amount of influence. Although presidents do not possess enough influence to dominate Congress, to force the legislature to accede to their every demand, they do possess enough influence to win on a significant number of roll calls that the president's side would otherwise lose. By winning on more roll calls because of this influence, presidents can affect the public policies produced through the legislative process.

This study conducted several types of analyses to estimate the amount of presidential influence. Since it can be hard to isolate causal effects with observational data, this research paired regression with quasi-experimental treatment effects analyses. The treatment effects analysis for the years 1953 to 2012 suggests that when the president takes a roll call position, the president’s side will win an additional 9% of House floor votes, or about five out of the fifty-four roll call positions that presidents take, on average, annually. Although five additional victories may not sound like much, if it leads to five major policy enactments, it may be consequential for the lives of citizens.2

Moreover, five additional pieces of legislation add up over the years—in a four-year term, there might be twenty additional enactments. From another perspective, Ansolabehere, Palmer, and Schneer (2016, 2018) estimate that there are eight or nine major legislative enactments per Congress from 1789 to 2010 and about seventeen from 1953 to 2010. The estimated five additional pieces of legislation presidents receive from position taking is nearly 30% of major enactments in the late modern period, assuming all the additional presidential wins are on major legislation. Through position taking, presidents can have consequential impacts on the nation's policies.

As conceptualized here, presidential influence is rooted in the office and in the surrounding political environment, termed "institutional presidential influence." There is some similarity between this conceptualization of influence and studies that emphasize the importance of contextual and political factors for presidential success (Bond and Fleisher 1990; Edwards 1990). But presidents still must decide whether to apply those institutional and contextual levers of influence; they need to be strategic decision makers, too. Hence, presidential influence is not merely a matter of dumb luck (Rockman 1981). Some presidents may be luckier than others, in that the office and the political environment provide them with greater resources, such as party control, upon which they can draw. But presidents still decide whether, when, how, and with whom they will exert effort, and how much, when trying to influence Congress.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.