Distribution isn’t redistribution
John Hills [ “Distribution and Redistribution”, Inequality and the State Oxford, 2004 online edn Oxford Academic, 20 Jan. 2005, https://doi.org/10.1093/0199276641.003.0008, accessed 2 July 2023.] //ahcchs
Distribution is a central issue in the appraisal of social and welfare policies. For some, it is the central issue when they make statements such as: ‘without a National Health Service providing free medical care, the poor could not afford treatment’; or ‘the primary aim of social security is preventing poverty’. Over twenty years ago, in his book The Strategy of Equality, Julian Le Grand (1982: 3) reached the striking conclusion that ‘Almost all public expenditure on the social services benefits the better off to a greater extent than the poor’. If so, a large part of social policy had failed in what many would see as one of its main aims. This conclusion was controversial (see Powell 1995, for a discussion of some of the issues, with a response from Le Grand). As we shall see below, the answer to this kind of question depends critically on a particular series of choices in the way in which distribution is analysed. Alternative ways of looking at the problem can give different answers. Whether redistribution is occurring or not can depend on the point of analysis. Under private insurance for, say, burglaries, a large number of people make annual payments (insurance premiums) to an insurance company, but only a small number receive payouts from the company. After the event (ex post) there is redistribution from the (fortunate) many to the (unfortunate) few. But, looking at the position in advance (ex ante), not knowing who is going to be burgled, all pay in a premium equalling their risk of being burgled, multiplied by the size of the payout if this happens (plus the insurance company's costs and profits). In ‘actuarial’ terms there is no redistribution—people have arranged a certain small loss (the premium) rather than the risk of a much larger loss (being burgled without insurance). Similarly, much of the welfare state is insurance against adversity. People ‘pay in’ through tax or National Insurance Contributions, but in return, if they are the ones who become ill or unemployed, the system is there to protect them. It does not make sense just to look at which individual happens to receive an expensive heart bypass operation this year and present him or her as the main ‘gainer’ from the system. All benefit to the extent that they face a risk of needing such an operation. The system is therefore often best appraised in actuarial terms; that is, in terms of the extent someone would expect to benefit on average. Equally, if we look at pension schemes over a single year, some people pay in contributions while others receive pensions. On this snapshot, there is apparently redistribution from the former to the latter. But, with a longer time horizon, today's pensioners may simply get back what they paid in earlier.