A well funded IRS is key to equality and tax disputes.
Marr 7/12/22. Chuck Marr is the Vice President for Federal Tax Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. From 1999 through 2004, he was Economic Policy Advisor to Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle and Senior Advisor for Budget Policy at the National Economic Council from 1997 through 1999 during the second term of President Clinton. Tax policy was a key area of responsibility in both these positions. In addition, earlier in his career he worked on the staffs of the Senate’s Budget and Banking committees. Prior to joining the Center in March of 2009, he was a senior political strategist in the Washington Research Group of Lehman Brothers and Barclays Capital, where he analyzed the impact of public policy on financial markets. He has also taught as an adjunct professor at Georgetown University. “Success of the IRS Rebuilding and Tax Gap Reduction Effort Depends on Sufficient Funding Through Annual Appropriations” https://www.cbpp.org/research/federal-tax/success-of-the-irs-rebuilding-and-tax-gap-reduction-effort-depends-on. Accessed July 2nd 2023. -TP
Significant IRS funding boosts are necessary after a decade of steep cuts left the agency ill equipped to provide the customer service taxpayers deserve — 7 in 10 taxpayer phone calls went unanswered in 2019 — or to enforce the nation’s tax laws.The agency has fewer auditors who handle the most sophisticated tax returns than it has had since the early 1950s, when the economy was far smaller and less complex. This depletion of the audit staff comes at a time when an estimated $470 billion a year in legally owed taxes goes uncollected, disproportionately from high-income taxpayers.[2] Reports have shown how overmatched IRS staff is in detecting and countering tax evasion schemes of large corporations and the nation’s wealthiest.[3] The audit rates for millionaires and the largest corporations fell roughly 77 percent and 56 percent, respectively, between 2010 and 2017.[4] The Inflation Reduction Act’s funding will help the IRS fill its budget shortfall while offering a degree of certainty that will enable the agency to rebuild its depleted customer service capacity and make long-term investments in its decades-old computer systems, as well as to hire and train new staff who can conduct sophisticated audits of high-income and high-wealth tax evaders, so the agency can do more both to improve customer service and detect tax cheating. But these funds are designed to supplement and not to supplant the agency’s regular budget, which is set each year through the annual appropriations process. The ultimate success of this effort to rebuild the IRS, improve customer service, and reduce the tax gap hinges on what Congress does starting this December, when it is scheduled to set base funding for the IRS in fiscal year 2023. This two-pronged funding approach follows a successful model already in place in a program that targets Medicare and Medicaid fraud, and it recognizes the need for cooperation among congressional tax-writing and appropriations committees. When drafting the Inflation Reduction Act, the tax-writing committees — Senate Finance and House Ways and Means — understood the IRS’ needs stemming from its ten-year budget shortfall and provided funding to help fill that gap. The Senate and House Appropriations committees, meanwhile, need to continue to provide base funding each year in the appropriations process while also continuing their valuable advisory and oversight roles traditional to the annual appropriations process, as Treasury and the IRS submit detailed information required as part of their budget request for the agency. The Biden Administration’s request for base funding of $14.1 billion for 2023, up from the $12.6 billion enacted for the agency in 2022, is an encouraging sign for the success of this effort. It, along with the Inflation Reduction Act funding, would put the IRS budget close to the funding level that would have existed if not for the cuts that began in 2011, allowing the agency to keep up both with inflation and with the expanding scope of its work in an increasingly complex and global economy. The House and Senate appropriations bills each included $13.6 billion for the IRS, enough to keep pace with inflation over the past year. But the Administration’s request would put the IRS in a better position to fix major shortfalls, not just keep them from getting worse. And while some Republican lawmakers have made reckless statements regarding the agency’s rebuilding effort in recent months,[5] there’s also been bipartisan interest in ensuring the IRS can improve its enforcement function. The Trump Administration’s 2020 and 2021 budgets proposed additional funding “for new and continuing investments to expand and strengthen tax enforcement.”[6] And during negotiations over how to pay for proposed infrastructure legislation in 2021, a group of Senate Republicans supported a separate mandatory funding stream for the IRS to boost tax enforcement and reduce the tax gap.[7] In addition, key Republicans have made helpful observations noting the IRS’ inability to answer taxpayer phone calls.[8] The upcoming base funding appropriations deliberations provide the opportunity to address this problem through adequate customer service funding. At issue is whether policymakers will side with honest taxpayers and provide the resources the IRS needs to give taxpayers the customer service they deserve — including making it easier to file a tax return, answering taxpayer questions, and providing timely refunds — while ensuring that wealthy people and large corporations that may be inclined to game the tax system are paying the taxes they legally owe. If policymakers stay committed to the IRS rebuilding plan, the nation will have a fairer, more user-friendly, and responsive tax system, and the agency will be far better equipped to perform a basic function of government: to enforce the tax laws Congress enacts to raise the revenue to pay for our military, for key benefit programs such as Social Security, and for the rest of the federal government’s operations. Severely Depleted IRS Urgently Needs Rebuilding Appropriations for the IRS — referred to in this piece as “base funding” in contrast to the $80 billion of multi-year mandatory funding in the Inflation Reduction Act — were repeatedly cut in real terms over the last decade-plus and remain more than 20 percent below their 2010 level, after adjusting for inflation. As a result, the agency has been forced to cut more than a fifth of its staff.[9]