Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Tax code EXTREMELY complex now

Burman and Gale, 2001, Leonard E. Burman, director of the Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center, and William G. Gale, senior fellow in Economic Studies at Brookings Institution, A Golden Opportunity to Simplify the Tax System: Options for Reforming a Complex Tax Code. April 3, 2001 Brookings institution. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/a-golden-opportunity-to-simplify-the-tax-system-options-for-reforming-a-complex-tax-code/ /cmm

Most of the debate about President Bush’s tax proposals and Democratic alternatives has focused on the highly contentious issues of size and fairness. The effects on tax complexity have been largely ignored, despite widespread consensus that taxes are too complicated. With both parties interested in tax cuts of some kind, this is a prime opportunity to simplify the tax system. In this brief, we discuss why taxes are complicated, examine how the Bush administration’s and the Democrats’ proposals would affect tax complexity, and present options for simpler taxes.

POLICY BRIEF #77

Tax complexity is like the weather: everyone talks about it but nobody does anything about it. This year’s debate is no exception. The way things are going, taxes will end up more complicated after the next round of “reform.” Unlike the weather, though, policymakers can do something about complexity. And if they do not simplify the tax system now, when there are surplus funds to pay for simplification, they will have lost a golden opportunity.

Simpler taxes are needed for many reasons. First and foremost, tax complexity creates headaches for almost all taxpayers. Complex taxes are difficult to comply with and to administer. Provisions aimed at encouraging certain activities—such as saving for college—will be less effective if people cannot understand how they work. People who do not understand tax rules may also question the fairness of the tax system, feeling that others are receiving more benefits than they are. As a result, these taxpayers may be less apt to comply with the law.

Why Are Taxes So Complex?

Any plea for simpler taxes has to start by addressing a basic problem: If everyone thinks taxes should be simple, why are taxes so complicated? We believe five factors help explain why taxes get complicated and suggest keys to making taxes simpler.

First, simplicity often conflicts with other tax policy goals. Most people believe taxes should be fair, conducive to economic prosperity, and enforceable, as well as simple. Even people who agree on these goals often disagree about the relative importance of each. As a result, policies usually represent a balance among competing goals, and simplicity often loses out to competing goals. For example, most countries tailor tax burdens to the characteristics of individual taxpayers. That can make taxes fairer, but also more complex. Income has to be traced from businesses to individuals. Individual characteristics such as marital status and number of dependents, as well as the composition of expenditures or income, have to be reported and documented. These conflicts appear to have been especially relevant in the Clinton administration, where desires to channel tax cuts to particular groups added significant complexity to tax rules especially for middle-income households.

Second, the political process creates complexity. Politicians and interest groups support tax subsidies for particular groups or activities. Targeted subsidies inevitably complicate the tax system by creating distinctions among taxpayers and among sources and uses of income.

Third, some complexity is necessary to deter tax avoidance. Taxpayers have every right to reduce their taxes by any legal means. But this activity inevitably raises questions about whether particular activities or expenditures qualify for tax-preferred status. The Treasury Department responds with complex rules designed to limit avoidance. Taxpayers in turn respond by inventing complex transactions to skirt the new rules. This can create a vicious cycle that leads to more and more complex rules and increasingly sophisticated and complex avoidance strategies.

Fourth, many complicated provisions were enacted to raise revenue or limit revenue losses during times of rampant budget deficits. For example, the landmark Tax Reform Act of 1986 (TRA)—a remarkable accomplishment in many respects—fell short of its goal of simplicity in order to meet the requirement of “revenue neutrality.” TRA created several complicated phase-outs and hidden taxes in order to raise revenue and meet distributional targets.

Lastly, complexity is hard to quantify. If members of Congress knew that a particular provision would raise compliance costs by a particular number of dollars, they could more easily evaluate the trade-offs between complexity and other goals.

Insofar as complexity has arisen from efforts to limit revenue loss, the surplus and the political consensus in favor of tax cuts creates an opportunity to simplify taxes. But simplification will not prove easy. Trade-offs among policy goals, political haggling, and taxpayer avoidance will affect any tax system and will limit how simple taxes can be.

Given the policy trade-offs, the fundamental question is not the overall level of complexity, but whether its benefits—in terms of achieving other policy goals—are worth the costs of complexity. This assessment can be tricky. Most people don’t mind complexity that directly reduces their taxes, but that does not necessarily make such complexity a good idea from society’s point of view. For example, suppose every taxpayer had to complete five extra lines of the tax form in order to receive a $1,000 tax cut. Each person filing might regard that as “good complexity,” worth the cost of providing extra information. But, if the intent is for revenues to remain constant, the funds would still have to be raised from somewhere, so the average taxpayer would receive no benefit from the good complexity. Thus, on balance, individuals’ tax bills are not lower, but taxpayers would have to work a lot harder to figure out what they owe. So, even what seems to be “good” complexity from the individual’s point of view can be an illusion, and an unambiguous loss for society.

Simplification in the President’s Plan

President Bush’s proposed tax cut is dominated by four main components: reductions in the marginal income tax rates, creation of a new 10-percent income tax bracket, expansion of the child credit, and abolition of the estate tax. But for issues of simplification, the devil is almost always in the details, and the president also offers a large set of additional proposals (see chart). Would taxes be simpler under the president’s plan? Probably not.

Income Tax Rate Cuts

Contrary to some claims, reducing the number of tax brackets does not simplify compliance. Taxpayers will continue to look up their tax liability in a tax table. But lower tax rates simplify tax compliance indirectly by reducing the incentive to avoid taxes or find tax shelters. They are one way to break the vicious cycle described earlier.

Alternative Minimum Tax

Any gains in simplicity arising from lower rates would be offset several times over because lower rates would subject millions of taxpayers to the individual alternative minimum tax (AMT). The AMT is a parallel tax system that was created to prevent high-income taxpayers from aggressively using tax shelters and deductions to eliminate their tax burdens. Taxpayers must pay the AMT if their regular income tax liability is less than their AMT liability. The AMT is quite complex and requires tax filers to make many detailed calculations. Currently, fewer than 2 million taxpayers face the AMT.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.