IRS is overwhelmed, understaffed, and vastly technologically behind – and future progress is lacking
Samuel Hammond and David Koggan sam hammond is the director of poverty and welfare policy at the Niskanen Center in Washington. david koggan is a student at Carnegie Mellon University and recent Niskanen Center policy intern. [“Saving the IRS”, Milken Institute Review, published 01-24-2022, https://www.milkenreview.org/articles/saving-the-irs. Accessed 07/03/2023.] //ahcchs
If taxes are the “,” as the Supreme Court has often reaffirmed, then the IRS is the heart that keeps the federal government’s blood pumping. Virtually every public function relies on the revenue collected by the IRS, including our capacity to underwrite a growing public debt without runaway inflation. But, stretching the metaphor a bit further, the 68-year-old agency’s risk of cardiac arrest is clearly growing. Decades of workforce and budget cuts have left the IRS short of personnel and money: was 19 percent lower in 2021 than in 2010, giving the agency roughly the same inflation-adjusted budget it had 30 years ago. This, despite needing to process over twice the number of business tax returns annually, all while administering an increasingly complex tax code that saddles the agency with growing responsibilities in social welfare and regulatory policy that the agency was never designed to handle. And with nearly to retire, the agency’s staffing crisis is set to grow much worse. This mismatch of responsibilities and resources is not helped by the IRS’s floppy-disc technical infrastructure. The backend of the IRS is the all-important Individual Master File. Used to store and process tax submissions, the IMF is programmed in impenetrable assembly code that literally dates from the Kennedy administration. Translating the code into Java, a comparatively modern programming language, has been a long-term goal of the IRS — but one which has faced repeated and often . And while the agency is formally committed to a broad-based modernization initiative, progress reports have been lacking. As this is being written, the Biden administration is pressing for a considerable increase in the IRS’s enforcement budget. But with lawmakers delegating more and more responsibility to the IRS, it will take more than a boost to its enforcement muscle to bring the agency into the 21st century. The agency was last restructured in 1998 — when we still feared the new millennium might cause a computer-induced apocalypse. Technology has advanced by leaps and bounds in the decades since, but in dealing with the nation’s tax and transfer system has in some ways regressed. This is partly because the IRS is drowning in mission creep, as Congress has found it convenient to expand the agency’s tasks far beyond the business of collecting taxes. Want to know the rules for government programs ranging from opportunity zones to a ? Ask the IRS, although it may take a few years to get back to you. Administering complex tax expenditures and social programs has stretched the agency thin. One way or another, the agency’s bloated mission needs to be devolved, with sufficient resources appropriated to give it a chance to do its core job well. However, achieving these reforms will be impossible without first fixing the broken funding and oversight mechanisms that have long exposed the IRS to politicization.