Now is the time for state government – Congressional gridlock will halt federal policymaking
Bromley-Trujillo and Nolette 6/23 Rebecca Bromley-Trujillo, B.A. in political science from the University of Texas, San Antonio and M.A. and Ph.D. in political science from Michigan, Paul Nolette, Associate Professor and Director of the Les Aspin Center for Government. 6-14-2023, "The State of American Federalism 2022–2023: Escalating Culture Wars in the States," OUP Academic, https://academic.oup.com/publius/advance-article/doi/10.1093/publius/pjad026/7198200?searchresult=1 – mostate JG
Recent congressional actions (or inaction) hold significant implications for federalism along two primary avenues: First, congressional gridlock typically has the byproduct of pushing policy issues onto subnational government agendas (Karch 2020). Second, it is common for federal legislation to include aspects of implementation that are left up to the states. A long line of scholarship shows that policy implementation is heavily influenced by political factors and state capacity levels (e.g., Dahill‐Brown and Lavery 2012). Moreover, implementation can be substantially affected when federal and state policy actors are in conflict over public policy goals. As Goelzhauser and Rose (2017) note, state–federal relationships are heavily influenced by partisan disagreements. The 117th Congress passed several major pieces of legislation in 2022, including the Inflation Reduction Act, legal protections for marriage equality, the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, and security assistance to Ukraine, among others. The passage of multiple significant bills through Congress represents somewhat of a departure from the legislative gridlock that largely defined the Trump years (Smith 2021). Bipartisan policy passage provides some evidence of this; fourteen House Republicans along with fifteen Senate Republicans joined Democrats to pass the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act, a law that followed a mass shooting that killed nineteen children in an elementary school in Uvalde, Texas. The law’s major provisions include investments in mental health services and federal grant money provided to the states to implement red flag laws. In another show of bipartisanship, Congress also enacted the Respect for Marriage Act, with thirty-nine Republicans in the House and twelve Republicans in the Senate joining Democrats in support of the legislation. In addition, there was overwhelming support from both parties for aid packages to support Ukraine in its fight against Russia. By this evidence alone, one might argue that Congress has moved beyond the consistent gridlock of years past. If gridlock were to truly subside, this would take some pressure off of subnational governments to fill policy voids on contentious issues.
Still, there is ample evidence that the parties remain heavily polarized and generally unable or unwilling to compromise on legislation. When measuring congressional productivity Binder (2004) argues that we must account for the denominator and compare legislative successes relative to legislative failures. In 2022, Congress remained deadlocked on a vast array of highly salient policy issues including voting rights, immigration, and reproductive rights. Each of these policy issues garnered significant public attention; however, political polarization, narrow party margins in Congress, and institutional features including the filibuster in the Senate largely prevented action by Congress. Lack of action on each of these key issues creates both opportunities for states to act and also significant challenges. For instance, states that border Mexico are bearing the brunt of a lack of federal immigration policy reform, which has exacerbated conflicts between states as well. In addition, a lack of uniform voting requirements at the federal level means that voting rights vary extensively across the states, resulting in voters experiencing drastically different “costs of voting” depending on the state in which they reside (Schraufnagel et al. 2022).
Partisan polarization and associated challenges with bipartisan compromise are also evident when looking at the laws that Congress enacted in 2022. For instance, the Inflation Reduction Act passed entirely along partisan lines through use of budget reconciliation, with no support from Republicans. In addition, laws that were passed with the support of both parties were significantly watered down to achieve compromise. The Bipartisan Safer Communities Act fell short of many advocates’ hopes for major gun control reforms. In addition, while Congress approved recognition of gay marriages performed in other states through the Respect for Marriage Act, this law stopped well short of guaranteeing the ability to marry in all states. As such, if the precedent established in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015) is overturned, same-sex marriages cannot be performed in several states without passage of new laws guaranteeing this right. In addition, though history was made in confirming Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson as the first Black woman to serve on the U.S. Supreme Court, the vote was predominantly along partisan lines with only three Republicans joining Democrats in support of her nomination.
Several of the laws passed by Congress also have significant implications for federalism. For example, many of the climate provisions in the Inflation Reduction Act require state implementation and/or additional steps by subnational governments and the private sector to ensure that the incentives built into the law are fully utilized. In addition, the Bipartisan Safer Communities Act includes federal grants that states can use to improve mental health treatment and implement red flag laws. Also, the Respect for Marriage Act (in conjunction with the potential for Obergefell to be overturned) has raised the salience of protection for same-sex marriage in states that have not already codified that protection in their constitutions or state laws. In addition, the aforementioned inability of Congress to pass major legislation related to voting, immigration, and reproductive rights has shifted policy conflicts to subnational governments, as will be discussed later in this overview.