Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

federalism on the brink

Diane Katz, 11-30-2021, Former Senior Research Fellow in Regulatory Policy, "Federalism in Crisis: Urgent Action Required to Preserve Self-Government," Heritage Foundation, https://www.heritage.org/conservatism/report/federalism-crisis-urgent-action-required-preserve-self-government -- MoState JG

The federal government’s continuous breach of constitutional constraints is approaching a crisis point. Countless regulatory and statutory mandates are supplanting states’ governance over matters properly under their purview, including education, law enforcement, public health, infrastructure, insurance, land use, and even civil service.2 States have also become inordinately dependent on federal funding,3 which skews local priorities and imposes a multitude of burdensome obligations.4 Imbalance in the federal–state relationship has profound effects on self-government. The U.S. Constitution unequivocally limits federal authority in order to impede the consolidation of power, as well as to maximize political accountability, policy innovation, and civic participation. To the extent that Washington violates constitutional strictures and usurps states’ authority, the functions of federalism are thwarted.

There is abundant evidence of excessive encroachment: The number and cost of federal mandates have increased markedly—an additional 457 enacted between 2006 and 2019 —as have pre-emptions6 of state and local authority. States are also more dependent on federal grants-in-aid, which comprised 32.4 percent of total state spending in fiscal year (FY) 2020.7 Outlays for the federal regulatory bureaucracy have grown by 18 percent in the past decade, to $66.2 billion in FY 20208 —excluding budgets and staffing for tax functions, entitlement programs, and government procurement. Federal dictates have likewise engulfed private enterprise, including 856 new mandates between 2006 and 2019.9

Not only has federal power expanded in scope, it has also become increasingly coercive, including the effective takeover of public education, reams of health care dictates, and prohibitions on states’ appeals of federal property takings.10 The recently enacted COVID-19 “relief” act, titled the American Rescue Plan,11 prohibits states from enacting tax cuts as a condition of aid. A number of other drastic measures are also in the pipeline. The Democrats’ H.R. 1 legislation, the so-called For the People Act, would override states’ election laws,12 while the House-passed Protecting the Right to Organize (PRO) Act would prohibit state right-to-work laws. States periodically assert their sovereignty on select policy issues, as has occurred with immigration enforcement, physician-assisted suicide, same-sex marriage, and recreational use of marijuana.13 Most recently, 23 states announced their intention to opt out of federally funded enhanced unemployment benefits related to COVID-19,14 which appear to be a disincentive to work.15

In some cases, states’ pushback is a matter of partisan politics rather than principle. In President Donald Trump’s first year, for example, Democratic states filed 35 lawsuits against the Administration (compared to 46 lawsuits filed by Republicans during the eight years of the Obama Administration).16 Regardless of motivation, states’ legal victories these days are overwhelmed by the extent of the federal power grab, which stokes conflict and divisiveness by heightening the political stakes of even mundane matters. Much of the Biden Administration’s agenda (in concert with congressional Democrats) will exacerbate the intergovernmental imbalance. President Joe Biden’s run of executive orders has dismantled a host of regulatory restraints, while his to-do list reflects the progressive conceit that government can remedy every economic hardship and cultural conflict, and all manner of human fallibility.17

This Special Report assesses the accumulation of mandates, pre-emptions, and other types of federal arm-twisting. Its purpose is to establish a baseline for monitoring changes in the mandate burden, and to spotlight the erosion of federalism. Equally important, this report counters claims that federalism is an obsolete concept.18 Previous efforts to curb intergovernmental meddling, such as enactment of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA), have largely failed, and systemic reforms are sorely needed. Both Democrats and Republicans have contributed to the problem, and reversing course will require action by both factions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.