Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Expansion of federal grants collapse federalism – division of powers, waste, dependency

CAGW, 3-1-2022, "Federalism and Federal Grants," Citizens Against Government Waste, https://www.cagw.org/reporting/federal-grants -- MoState JG

The expansion of federal grants to the states and the replacement of the Constitution’s system of divided powers with one of coercive federalism has had a detrimental impact on the states. Grant programs not only erode the division of powers between the states and the federal government established by the Constitution, but also fuel wasteful practices and unsustainable spending. The most significant problem with federal grants is their impact on the federalist system. Roosevelt’s New Deal and Johnson’s Great Society led the shift to cooperative and then coercive federalism. Thanks in part to the expansion of federal grants, American intergovernmental relations no longer resemble James Madison’s vision of how powers should be divided between the federal government and the states. The expansion of federal power allows for greater control from a centralized government. Central control, in turn, undercuts the protections provided by a decentralized system and the ability of states and localities to make decisions best suited to their circumstances. Restrictive grants to the states allow the federal government to set and execute policy priorities that are inconsistent and contradictory from one administration to another. In 1987, the Supreme Court ruled that Congress could attach conditions related “to the federal interests in particular national projects or programs” to federal funds in order to implement preferred policies.32 Congress and federal agencies have increasingly expanded this approach in recent years. For example, the evaluation criteria for the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s ReConnect Loan and Grant broadband expansion program gives preference to applicants “who commit to net neutrality” principles, a policy priority of the Biden administration that was in place during the Obama administration and then eliminated by the FCC during the Trump administration.33 Initial guidelines for ARPA spending stipulated that state and local governments could not use any of those funds to reduce taxes. The impact of coercive grants on state sovereignty fuels other issues. Most notably, as grant money moves further away from the issuing agency, spending becomes harder to track. In cases “where the Federal Government compels States to regulate,” Justice Sandra Day O’Connor wrote in New York v. United States, “the accountability of both state and federal officials is diminished.”34 This problem is exacerbated by the lack of a uniform reporting standard for the states and federal agencies. For example, the Community Development Block Grant-Disaster Recovery (CDBG-DR) program was established in 1993 to provide long-term recovery aid to areas hit hard by natural disasters. Since that time, the program has struggled with funding delays and wasteful spending. A January 2021 Urban Institute report “found that CDBG-DR grants took an average of 4.7 years to complete.”35 A May 2021 Government Accountability Office (GAO) report found that the constant transfer of funds through different entities before it reaches recipients made the program ripe for abuse.36 Despite the risk and concerns that federal oversight becomes more difficult once funds reach the states, the Department of Housing and Urban Development has doled out $40 billion to states and localities in response to disasters since 2017, nearly half of the $90 billion distributed since the inception of CDBG-DR.37 This increased spending has expanded involvement federal control over what were once considered state and local emergencies.

When federal grants dry up, states must find other ways to offset the lost funding either through increasing revenue or eliminating the programs. After the passage of the ARRA in 2009, for example, many states used federal grant funds to support the establishment of new programs or prop up existing programs that would normally be cut. Within a few years, the funds provided by the federal government expired, and the states found themselves unable to continue the programs. A May 11, 2020, Reason Foundation report examined the implementation of state education funds received under the ARRA in light of calls for aid to the states in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic. The report found that several states spent federal education funding on projects unrelated to the legislation’s intent. Texas placed its education money in a fund that disproportionally benefited higher-income school districts that were less impacted by the Great Recession than schools in low-income areas. North Carolina spent money “via mechanisms that aren’t directly based on overall student counts or needs,” leading to federal relief money being spent on programs “like professional development, driver training for ninth-graders, and gifted and talented education.”38 Strict regulation of federal funds, on the other hand, increases federal control over the states and risks violating state sovereignty. Just as Hoover predicted in 1932, state and local governments have learned to rely on the federal government to provide a bailout during times of economic downturn. When states fail to prepare, it allows them to shift the burden to the federal government and other states. The Mercatus Center’s Veronique de Rugy and Tad DeHaven noted that “it is fair to ask…why taxpayers in states like New Mexico should be responsible for covering for the insufficient planning of states like Pennsylvania.”39 Relief grants allow poorly prepared states to benefit from the stability of other states and their taxpayers. As more states recognize that they do not need to prepare for future downturns or spend money that they set aside for emergencies, they will continue to take steps to maximize federal assistance. After the Great Recession, most states took steps to prepare for an economic downturn. A “stress test” of the states performed by Moody’s Analytics in 2019 found that 28 states held enough cash on hand to weather a moderate recession without turning to tax hikes or spending cuts. 40 Of the remaining 22 states, 12 were “within striking distance” of the goal and the remaining 10 were “significantly underprepared” for even a moderate downturn. In the end, the federal response to the pandemic demonstrated that states did not need to take steps to prepare for downturns because the federal government was standing by to bail them out. To help offset projected budget shortfalls, the federal government pumped trillions of dollars into all the states to offset revenue loss, even if they were running surpluses. In the end, the states were left with far more money than they needed to break even. Federal grants allowed every state, both those that had prepared well and those that hadn’t prepared at all, to expand funding into a wide variety of programs they could not afford to establish before. One year after the declaration of the COVID-19 national emergency, the data showed that only 15 states experienced a decrease in their rainy-day funds. Of the remaining 35 states, all but two “reported higher balances” than before the pandemic.41 The influx of federal funds allowed states to increase spending without tapping into their reserves.

States have also learned to rely on federal funding to respond to natural disasters. Programs like the CDBG-DR allow states to defer costs and responsibilities to the federal government. Federal disaster relief programs force states in the interior of the country to provide additional funding to coastal states typically hit hardest by natural disasters. When states rely extensively on federal funds and shift their own spending elsewhere, citizens in other states pay the price. State reliance on and use of federal funds creates a system of dependency and increases the opportunity for waste, fraud, and abuse of government programs. When states become flush with federal money, the opportunities for individuals to take advantage of the funds increases dramatically. Reporting on the first tranche of ARPA grants uncovered a wide array of wasteful projects unrelated to economic recovery.42 In one of the most egregious examples, Wisconsin’s Whitewater Independent School District (ISD) school board voted to allocate 80 percent of the District’s ARPA funds to the construction of synthetic turf fields for baseball, softball, and football. The district possessed a rare opportunity to improve their facilities, Whitewater High School Athletic Director Robert Crandall told the board as the district was not one “that would go to a referendum for turf fields.”43 Unfortunately, Whitewater ISD was not alone in its decision to take advantage of federal funds. School districts across the nation poured funds into projects that were tangential at best to the pandemic and education.44 Presented with the opportunity, state and local governments often use federal relief funds to expand existing programs or establish new ones without a full consideration of their long-term impact. The various impacts and consequences of the federal grant regime underscore the need for dramatic reform. Without serious changes, the problematic impacts of federal grants on the states will continue to magnify. The Build Back Better Act, which passed the House of Representatives on November 19, 2021, and currently awaits a vote in the Senate, takes each of these concerns to the next level.45 The legislation includes requirements that states prioritize programs that “expand equitable outdoor access” on non-Federal land for “underserved groups” in addition to a variety of other conditions, which allows the federal government to dictate policy to the states.46 The rise of coercive federalism made possible by the expansion of federal grants makes the states accessories to the waste, fraud, and abuse prevalent in these programs while they undercut the authority and power of the states to make independent decisions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.