Private sector key to federalism – local autonomy
Ladner, Andreas, et al. 2017, University of Lausanne Professor, Swiss Graduate School of Public Administration, “Autonomy and Austerity: Re-Investing in Local Government.” The Future of Local Government in Europe: Lessons from Research and Practice in 31 Countries, edited by Christian Schwab et al., 1st ed., Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH, 2017, pp. 23–52. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv941qjd.6. – mostate JG
There are basically three directions municipalities can take when looking for alternative ways to provide their tasks and services. A first direction can be termed cooperation with the private sector. This entails different forms of outsourcing or purchasing of services and public-private partnerships. The spectrum is wide and the terminology varies, but the basic idea is that the municipality still has the last word but takes advantage of the competence of and the opportunities offered by private actors. The second possibility is the joint provision of tasks and services with other municipalities. Inter-municipal cooperation is a way to optimize the catchment area of a task, which results in lower costs or more professional provision. This is often seen as an alternative to amalgamations and offers the advantage that the catchment areas can be adapted according to the requirements of each specific task. The last possibility is intensified cooperation with higher levels of state. This must not be confounded with transferring the task to the higher level, which is nothing but centralization. The municipalities still contribute to the funding and by doing so – following the principle of fiscal equivalence – they should also keep some decisional power.
To what extent do these reforms have an impact on the autonomy of local government? Outsourcing, or more intensive cooperation with the private sector, does not necessarily lead to less autonomy, since the municipalities remain in charge of these tasks and services. One of the problems arising here is what political scientists call the ‘principal-agent’ problem. The municipalities have the role of the principal. They take the final decisions, define the goals to be achieved and set the rules and conditions to respect. The private providers of the services are the agent. They know how to execute these tasks and retain all the important information. This gives them the chance to influence the terms of the contract in their interest. The municipalities depend on the know-how of their agents (private service providers). Although the municipalities’ autonomy is not reduced, they might lose some influence on the tasks and services provided. In an ideal form, however, they receive precisely what they want and might get it at a cheaper price.
As for inter-municipal cooperation, it is often argued that this reduces local autonomy since the municipality no longer decides alone on the provision of a specific task, but together with other municipalities. Some even argue that inter-municipal cooperation leads to retrenchment of local democracy. The effects of intensified cooperation depend to a large extent on the way it is organized. There are ways to increase democracy through service contracts and binding mandates, political steering and supervising boards, referendums and initiatives. A single municipality, nevertheless, depends more on other municipalities and therefore loses its independence. The scope of tasks municipalities organize autonomously without interference from higher state levels, however, remains unchanged. Intermunicipal cooperation thus reduces the autonomy of single municipalities, but not of the municipalities in general. Increased cooperation with higher levels of the state, on the contrary, can reduce the autonomy of the municipalities in general. This is particularly the case when the execution or the regulation of tasks and services is transferred to the higher levels of state. Following the broadly accepted principle of subsidiarity, transferring tasks to higher state levels should only take place when the lower levels are no longer able to fulfil this task and a countrywide solution is needed. Following the principle of fiscal equivalence, regulating, funding and executing should coincide on one level. Paying without any influence on the way public agents from the higher level do something is the worst case scenario for the municipalities. The – very unlikely – best case would be to receive all the money without any additional instructions so that they can use it for their own purposes according to their preferences.